denetor look palantir then boromir would have been at osgilioth :confused:

If Denethor didn't look into the Palantir, then Faramir would have been at the Black Gate.

well, worth a try...?
 

If Denethor didn't look into the Palantir, Denethor would have been at the Black gate.

Perks?

Firefoot has it!

If ________ had not become a ______, ______ and ______ would not have escaped from _______.

If Gorbag had not become a traitor, Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from Cirith Ungol.

If Grishnakh had not become a traitor, Merry and Pippin would not have escaped from the orcs.

"Frodo and Sam" is correct, but none of the rest is.

If Gollum had not become a guide, Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from the Dead Marshes?

Firefoot?

Oh, sorry. No, that's not what I had in mind.

if sam had not become a rinbearer frodo and sam would not have escaped mordor?

*shakes head*. Nope.

if aragron had not become a distraction then frodo and sam would have escpaed from mordor

Nope.

a hint perhaps?

The "If _____ had not become a _______" part happened in the First Age.

how far back the wizardss go but Ill take this guess

If Olorin had not become a wizard sam and frodo would not have escaped from mordor

Nope.

uh... another hint?

"escaped from _______" happens between Faramir and the escape from Cirith Ungol.

Galadxriel Ring bearer Frodo and Sam Shelob's Lair

"Shelob's lair" is correct.

If Earendil had not become a "simaril bearer", Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from Shelob's Lair?

Eärendil is correct.

If Earendil had not become a elf, Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from Shelob's Lair!

Try again!

If Earendil had not become a mariner, Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from Shelob's Lair?

Nope. It relates very directly to Frodo and Sam's situation.

If Earendil had not become a light, Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from Shelob's Lair?

BTW, congrats on being 100 posts away from 2,000 posts!

Very close, now. Thanks!

If Earendil had not become a star, Frodo and Sam would not have escaped from Shelob's Lair?

We have a winner! Your turn Perky.

If _______ wasn't _______, _______ wouldn't have _____.

If Cirdan wasn't sure, Gandalf wouldn't have Elven ring.

I have no idea lol.

I`m not very good at this, but I`ll take a random guess. ;)

If Gollum wasn`t clumsy, the ring wouldn`t have been destroyed?

Oh, never mind.

No far, nothing's right. Arwen Evenstar, it was a good try though!

If Túrin wasn't cursed, Beleg wouldn't have died.

Nope. And it's not from the First Age!