A weapon?

A weapon? No

Could it be cooked or was it used for cooking?

Could it be cooked or was it used for cooking? No

Was it owned by a hobbit?

Was it owned by a hobbit? Yes

Is it inside Bilbo's house?

Is it a piece of clothing? Can it be worn?

Is it owned by a hobbit other than Bilbo?

Is it inside Bilbo's house? Sometimes
Is it a piece of clothing? No
Can it be worn? No
Is it owned by a hobbit other than Bilbo? No

Bilbo's walking stick? Not sure if he had one, but I think he did (haven't got The Hobbit :().

The letter to Bilbo form the dwarves?

The letter to Bilbo form the dwarves? No
Bilbo's walking stick? No

Bilbo's pipe?

Bilbo's pipe? No

Bilbo's handkerchief?

Did he carry this object during his travel?

Is it mentioned in more than one sentence?

Bilbo's handkerchief? Yes

Your turn, Nil.

Thanks!
 

People no longer pre-empt. This is a scary precedent.

Start asking.

No more mithril for you!!
 

Is it an object?

Is it a place?

Does it belong to a Wizard?

That's because Saucepan came in a while ago and said stop asking pre-empt questions.

Anyhow, is it alive?

First Age?

Is it an event?

He did? Well, what a spoilsport! :rolleyes: ;)

Actually, I don't think that I ever did suggest that there should be no pre-emptive questions. Not on this thread, anyway.

So feel free to pre-empt away. Seems pointless to me, though, as the quesion-setter can just choose a subject to which the answer to the pre-emptive questions is "No". :p

Well, even without pre-emptive questions, one can change her mind too, before answering the first set of questions. I think pre-emptive questions just makes you make up your mind quicker. ;)

Anywhen...

Is it an object? No
Is it a place? Non
Does it belong to a Wizard? Nyet
Anyhow, is it alive? Nein
First Age? Nope
Is it an event? A-yup

Third Age?

Third Age? Yes

During the Great Years?

During the Great Years? No

Did it involve Hobbits?

West of the Misty Mountains?

Did it involve Hobbits? *shakes head*
West of the Misty Mountains? Sorry, no

In Gondor?

That's the place.
 

No, wait. I said event.

In Gondor? Yes

Does it involve fighting?

Did it happen while there was still a king in Gondor?

I'm assuming that people follow the spirit of the game and stick with what they first thought of. Am I assuming too much? :rolleyes: ;)

Did it involve a Steward?

Was it Strider's coronation?

Also, what are The Great Years?