So you don't mean "Is it one removed from Enedwaith?"

But I get it now...Not Aratar.

Drat!
 

:D

'Enedwaith' = anyway in my vocabulary. ;)

Is it alive before the World was formed?

Is is alive before the world was formed?

Come now, Nilp, that's a "was it" question. This isn't the "was it" game...

Plus I'm not entirely sure I've got your answer. Not Arien?

Re:
 

The question doesn't necessarily have to start with 'is it.' I just started my question with 'is it,' disregarding grammar, because I want it to fit the game's title.

Is it alive before the World was formed?

I wasn't complaining, just hedging for time...and maybe teasing you for your grammar, just a little bit ;)

Is it alive before the world was formed? Not Araw

Got me again.
 

Really sorry. :o I thought that . . . well, never mind. Again, really sorry.

So . . .

Is it where the wise turned back?

Wild Guess Ahead
 

Is it where the wise turned back?

Not Argonath?

Hehe.
 

:D

Is it where the wise turned back?

Grrr...
 

Not Aros?

A little alteration:
 

Is it where many of wise turned back?

Agh! Running out of place names...

Not Armenelos?

More modifications.
 

Is it where many of wise turned back and returned home?

Not Araman?

What happened?
 

Is it the last?

Not Arvedui.

Where's that paavo???
 

Is it the last?

He's hiding.
 

Not Ar-Pharazon.

*evil grin*
 

Is it the last?

Yes, dear, you're very scary.
 

Not Aragorn. (I suppose we'll go with last Ranger, rather than last King.)

Aw, shucks.
 

Is it the first?

*sigh*
 

Not Aranarth.

Must . . . get . . . another . . . letter . . .
 

Is it the first?

Not yet.
 

Not Ar-Adunakhor

Fiddlesticks!
 

Is it the worst?

What could possibly be worse than these vague questions?
 

I confess myself stymied. Give me your answer, and I'll give you your letter.

Success!
 

It's Ar-Gimilzôr, acclaimed worst enemy of the Elendili.

*grumbles*
 

Oh, fine...

ARA

The worst has arrived!
 

Who is hiding? where? When? Oh, you mean all the people who went to hiding when they saw my graceful figure approaching :p

Is there a chance of mistaking it for something much bigger? (You can add an "is it" there if you want ;) )

Not Araphant? (since it sounds like Oliphaunt?)

OoO! Tougher than you look! :)
 

Was he the son of the singer and the succesor of the greatest?

Is it the father and the son of the first and the last?

Was he the son of the singer and the succesor of the greatest? Not Aranel

And Nilp...

I have no clue. *sighs* Answer?

Erm . . .
 

After a check of the genealogy of the Line of Isildur, I discovered that my question is wrong. My answer was Arathorn, the second of which was the father of Aragorn (last non-King Chief of Rangers) and the first of which was (as I mistakenly thought) the son of the first Aragorn.

Ignore it. *sigh*

Did it have the same title as the wisest?

Hah!
 

Except that I don't know the answer to this question either. Drat!

Errors abound.
 

Aredhel's title was the White Lady, not just the White, which was also the title of Gandalf (aka Olórin, the wisest of the Maia).

I need to get some proper sleep . . . *sigh*

Well, I'll try one more time:

Is it on the edge of the wood with almost the same name as it?

Go back to bed...
 

I can't find an answer to this one, but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt...What's your answer?

Oh, dear . . .
 

I really should shut up now.

The first three letters are Ara . . . and my answer is Archet.

*bangs head on the nearest hard surface repeatedly*

I really don't think that's going to help...
 

And you seem to be having enough problems already. Where'd paavo go? I didn't think this would be that hard, really.

Re: paavo
 

He's been destroyed, along with a very special Bakuretsu Kage Bunshin of mine. ( :p to paavo)

Enedwaith, I think I've learned my lesson.

Check facts.

Starts with ARA.

Does it have something seemingly dirty in it's name?

Not Arassuil? (Similarity to "soil"?)