Does it have anything to do with light? Yes
Anyways, is it Arda? No

Does it have anything to do with stars?

Does it have anything to do with stars? Yes

Does it involve Varda?

The ships the stars were put in? Or something like that?

Does it involve Varda? Yes
The ships the stars were put in? Or something like that? No

Was it used more than once?

The sparks that sprang from Aulës anvil and became Stars?

Was it used more than once? Yes
The sparks that sprang from Aulës anvil and became Stars? No

Is it a tool?

The cauldron Kulullin or Silindrin?

Is it a tool? No
The cauldron Kulullin or Silindrin? YES!!!

Phew, that took long. It was Silindrin I had in mind. Firefoot, you're up. :)

And the mighty Firefoot takes the cake! Anyways, is it living?

I love this game. :)

Anyways, is it living? No

Is it an item?

Is it a place?

Is it an event?

First Age?

Is it a weapon?

Third Age?

I love it too. ;)

Second Age?

Is it an item? Yes
Is it a place? No
Is it an event? No
First Age? No
Is it a weapon? No
Third Age? Yes
Second Age? Probably

Is it larger than a man?

Is it larger than a man? No

Is it metal?

Is it metal? Yes

Is it a ring?

Is it a ring? No

Does it have magical properties?

Is it wearable?

Edible?
A tool?

Does it have magical properties? No
Is it wearable? No
Edible? No
A tool? No

Was it ever in the posession of a member of the fellowship?

Was it ever in the posession of a member of the fellowship? No

Owned by a elf?

Owned by a elf? Yes

Owned by a hobbit?

Owned by a hobbit? No

Owned by a man?

Owned by a man? No