nope!

here's a joke answer

bard's parents bard smaug

Hey dol, a joke indeed!

can we have a hint?

hmm, I suppose! The second blank is "dwarves."

Then the first blank is Aulë, & the third is... Smaug, I suppose.

Very good son of Numenor! You are up!

If _______ hadn't met ________, then Aragorn would never have met _________.

ill venture a try
 

elrond, celebrian, arwen?

Wow, I just realized how easy that one was. Sorry Downers. Your go, Dark Morsel.. er.. Morsul.

let's see

if _______ didnt go on an ________ then ________ would not have gone to _______.

(the last blank has multiple answers)

Gandalf, Eagle, Frodo, Rivendell?

thats not what im looking for although the last two are right

Bilbo, Adventure, Frodo, Rivendell?

but of course i would have also accepted mordor khazad-dum bree or anywhere else they went to

Ah! Thank you Morsul...
 

If ______ didn't take the _________, then ______ would not have named him _______.

ok here's a guess oh an by the way thanks for picking one I don't know!

I think it's Aragorn Throne Gandalf King
or Aragorn Crown Gandalf King

Nasty Bombadil, we hatesss him, oh yesss precious!
 

If Sméagol didn't take Ring, then his family would not have named him Gollum.

I thaught they called him Gollum before he had even gotten the ring, no?

No, he was Smeagol until the ring had taken over his mind. As for the question, mine's like Morsul's, but a little different. If Aragorn didn't take the elfstone, then Galadriel would not have named him Elessar

How's that Bombadil? ...Bombadil?

Fourth guess:
 

If Melkor didn't take the Silmarils, then Feanor would not have named him Morgoth.

Evisse has it nice!

Thanks!
 

If _____ had not followed _______, he would have been captured by ______.

If Frodo had not followed Gollum, he would have been captured by Sauron. (?)

If Sam had not followed Frodo, he would have been captured by Orks. (?)

Both of them are correct, but it was the second one that I had in mind. Go ahead, Divyan Redsmith. Oh and welcome to the 'Downs! :)

Thanks for the welcome.
Okay, I'm new at this so I hope that this works out.

If _____had not _____ away the _____, _____ may not have taken _____

to _____ _____ and _____ would not have become a _____.

If Saruman had not thrown away the palantir, Gandalf may not have taken Pippin
to Minas Tirith and Pippin would not have become a Guard (of the citadel).

Something like that?

Wow! Almost perfect Thorongil. Only the first blank is incorrect.

Sorry Thorongil :( If Wormtoung had not thrown away the palantir, Gandalf may not have taken Pippin to Minas Tirith and Pippin would not have become a Guard.

:D To The Perky Ent: You are right of course. Take it away.

That proves I got some reading to do. I should have known that.

Well this thread has been dormant. Let's wake it up! Anyways, here's the new question: If ____ didn't ___ into the _______, then _______ would have been at ___ _____ ____

IM pretty sure part of this is wrong but...
 

If Pippin didn't look into the palantir, then Gandalf would have been in the Ridder Mark?

nope!

I'm giving it a try:

If Frodo didn't look into the mirror of Galadriel, then Frodo would have been at the Old Forest.

It's probably wrong, but it's worth a shot! :D

if Gandalf didnt run into Radagast he would have been at The Prancing Pony? :rolleyes:

Nope, but good tries!

If Denethor didn't look into the Palantir, then Gandalf would have been at the Pelennor Fields.

Probably not right though.

The first two are right, but you've got the wrong person and the wrong battle.