Sam carries Frodo? Sam spares Gollum's life? Sam uses the Phial of Galadriel? Frodo attempts to keep the Ring? Frodo's burden is lifted? Gwaihir saves Sam and Frodo? Am I even getting close...? ;)

not at all.....just keep of the topic of sam and gollum............;)

Ok, both Sam and Gollum wanted to get the Ring of Frodo though for differnet reasons.

Sam threatens Gollum and lets him go?

Phial of Galadriel doesn't work...all powers except Sauron's subdued here at the heart of Sauron's realm.

Nirvana, do you mean keep "off" or "on" the topic of Gollum and Sam? "Of" doesn't make sense to me.:(

typo....i meant the word "off"

hint:think Frodo and something to do with the way he interacts with people

He becomes "the master of the Shire days" again; he makes Sauron scared of him.

nope....way off......it affects how he interacts with others

He becomes aggressive against Sam because of the Ring?

On the subject of what NightKnight was saying, HE doesn't care for Sam one wink once he puts on the ring

nope.....keep on keepin on......how long has this been goin????

Frodo Disappears?

nope :smokin:

He saves the party that marched on the black gate, not much longer could have they held out.....

Frodo cried out because Gollum bit him? Frodo's will was aroused? Frodo foretold Gollum would die? Frodo stands erect? These all seem pretty obscure to me - anything close?

This is ridiculously hard... who did Frodo interact with in this event?

Please could we have some clues here!?!
Is it even something to do with Frodo or are we supposed to be thinking of things that happened at that particular time or what?
Help please!

Obscenely hard, this. Frodo was seen by Sauron?

Nirvana II, you wouldn't do such a thing as put us on, would you?
 

Frodo speaks with a voice louder and clearer as ever before?

not yet.....but it DOES have to do with Frodo

How do you expect us to figure this out? Is it something that is actually said in the book (i.e. if the answer was Sam carried Frodo it says in the book "Sam picked Frodo up and carried him.")

Yes is it something that was written in the book or is it a film thing?
Please hints, clues, anything!

the brainstorming session continues...
 

Frodo held/put on the ring for the final time? Frodo felt the pain of losing the finger? and then of losing the ring? He selfishly refuses to think of the consequences his act may have for others? He challenges Sauron? Is this obscure enough yet? :p

Frodo looks evilly at Sam, therefore taunting him and teasing him before putting on the Ring? I can't believe you guys haven't gotten this yet... :p

Frodo was the first hobbit ever to step into Sammath Naur.

The first time Frodo had a none blade inflicted mortal wound?

ok...none right yet...nothing do do with Frodo's physical state-thingy

You've made this too hard for us. Give us a better clue. :p

p is for psychology

How many pages is it now?
 

Satisfying though it may be to see NightKnight admit that a question is too hard ( :p ;) ), he has a point. This question has gone on for far too long. I think that it's about time you started giving more obvious clues, Nirvana II. :rolleyes:

OK how about the ring finally overthrows Frodos mind?

not quite....that was the closest...ever

Frodo puts on the Ring for the last time?

Frodo stops being himself?

go on Kath....Fingolfin.....read the thread....i said nothing physical

Um, Frodo technically becomes the Dark Lord for a moment?

Frodo says farewell to Sam.....

was P a hint?
 

Frodo displays evidence of multiple Personality disorder? ~ Frodo uncovers the dark side of his Personality under the influence of the Ring?

Who take part of this event? Sam? Gollum?

Frodo claims the ring and Sauron is afraid of him?