Wow, first time at this game and I got it right!
 

Cheers symestreem.

How about T. -T

Tarondor son of Tarcil
or
Theoden, son of Thengel
or
Theodwyn, daughter of THengel
or
Theodred, son of Theoden
or
Thorin, son of Thrain
or
Thrain, son of Thror

One at a time please in a game like this, so as to give others a chance.

All wrong :p.

That was rather hypocritical Mr Saucepan Man sir.
Also, can we still ask questions for clues in this game?

Hypocritical?
 

It was neither critical nor hypocritical in intention. I was simply offering some guidelines. It rather spoils the game if one person types out every conceivable answer to a question in one post. And we are, after all, here to enjoy the games, are we not? :)

Sure. Why not.

Does it have to be their real name? If not could it be Turin son of Hurin Thalion?

Tar-Telperiën

Or Tar-Telemmaitë?

Thorongil has it.

How about... C.-C

Celebrimbor son of Curufin?

Nope.

Celebrian daugher of Celeborn?

Not that either.

Calimehtar, son of Calmacil?

Nope.

Cotman son of Cottar (hobbits)?

And...Nope.

Celebrindor son of Celepharn?

Wrong.

Not much happening here. Need a hint?

Yes please :).

They are Noldor. There are three different solutions. Either one of them will be accepted. Shouldn't be too hard now.

I think I have it: Celegorm/Curufin/Caranthir son of Curufinwë AKA Fëanor.

Bingo!!

Idril, daughter of Elenwe?

Nope.

Isildur, son of Elendil?

Incanus, son of Eru?

Firefoot has it. :)

O. P.

Odo Proudfoot?

Correctomundo!

Nimloth, daughter of Galathil?

Yep. :)

Cool,

E. -F

Elfstan Fairbairn?