I would think they would count as tangible, wouldn't they? Elves I mean; not all at the same time of course but since they are individually, I would have thought they would also be collectively.......but oh I don't know... and it ain't my question :cool:

Um, how about the elven people as a whole? Or any people? I don't understand the question, if you mean does it have anything to do with elven people as a whole the answer would be: The book does not specify.
the light of Earendil's star? No, but the you're close.
The Lay of Leithian?No
If not, ist it a Lay? No
The Lament for Gandalf? No
Is it a song? No
Err .... stab in the dark: "In western lands" Sam's song in Cirith Ungol? No

The light of the Silmarils?

The light of the Silmarils? No

I have no clue. This is a good one. Um...howabout....is it a lightsource?

The light the Elessar?

The light the Elessar? -No
Um...howabout....is it a lightsource? Yes

Is it the Remmirath?

Is it the Remmirath? - No

Is it a star(s)?

Is it a star? Yes.

Borgil?

Borgil? -No

There's one more I can think of without poring through my books....

Is it Menelvagor, the Swordsman in the Sky?

Is it the Sickle of the Valar?

Carnil?

Helluin?

Nénar?

Nénar? - No
Helluin? - No
Carnil? - No
Is it the Sickle of the Valar? - No
Is it Menelvagor, the Swordsman in the Sky? - No

Nenar

The sun? The Sun is counted a star in the real world so if you want the elvish name then Anar?

The Wain?

I don't think this counts as being intangible but-
The light from Sting when orcs/goblins are around?

The light from Sting when orcs/goblins are around? -No
The Wain? -No
The sun? The Sun is counted a star in the real world so if you want the elvish name then Anar?- No. I suppose the Sun is counted as a star, though

The Valacirya?

Soronúmë???

I'm really out of guesses here

Soronúmë??? -No
The Valacirya? -No

You guys should try a different approach here. :D

mental states... hm.

Did it evoke a joyful mental state?

Morwinyon, AKA Arcturus?

Is it the star of "Smith of Wootton Major"?

The Phial of Galadriel?

Its an item but it has starligh light and it is a different approach.

Is it the star of "Smith of Wootton Major"? - No
Morwinyon, AKA Arcturus? - No (Never heard of these before, Nightknight. Forgive my ignorance - where are they mentioned?)
Did it evoke a joyful mental state? - Yes
The Phial of Galadriel? - No
Oh and it's not the moon either. :p

Eh...I found them on a homepage. :p

Is it a constellation?

Is it mentioned in the Sil?

Did it evoke an emotion in more than one person?

Is it the stars in a spirit-like embodiment of Elbereth? :rolleyes:

Can it be held? *shrugs*

having lots of fun here :D
 

Can it be held? *shrugs* - No.

Is it the stars in a spirit-like embodiment of Elbereth? - No (though that would have been a nice one ;) )

Did it evoke an emotion in more than one person? - No (that being: it evoked an emotion in only one person)

Is it mentioned in the Sil? -No

Is it a constellation? - No

You're getting close!

The star Sam saw in Mordor?

YEEEEES!! Home run!
 

Yep, it's the tiny star that brings hope to Sam that beauty is forever and the shadow is only a passing thing.

Congrats, Nightknight!
*hands Nightknight the gold medal* :D