An event?

Right back at you, NightKnight:Speaks for itself, doesn't it?

Oops, didn't see that one. I guess we're even now. ;)

So, an object you say... Was it carried by a member of the Fellowship?

Was it carried by a member of the Fellowship? Yes

Was it carried by a Hobbit?

Was it carried by Aragorn?

Was it carried by a Hobbit? Yes
Was it carried by Aragorn? No

Was it in the Shire before WotR?

Is it made of metal?

Was it in the Shire before WotR? Yes
Is it made of metal? Yes

One guess to rule them all?
 

It's not the One Ring by any chance, is it?

Yes, actually it is the Ring. Your turn, Saucepan Man.

Hehe. Lucky guess! :cool:

Ask away.

I'll go first...
 

Can you wear it?

Is it living?

First Age?

A Place?

An event?

Can you wear it? No
Is it living? Yes
First Age? No
A Place? No
An event? No

Is it an elf?

No

Is it good?

Third Age?

Man?

Is it living? Yes
First Age? No

Is it good? No
Third Age? Yes
Man? Yes

Well that certainly narrows it down. :D

4th age?

Is it living? Yes
First Age? No
Is it good? No
Third Age? Yes
Man? Yes

4th age? No

And welcome both to the Downs and to the Quiz Room, Gandalf of the six asterisks! :)

2nd age?

Is it a man of Gondor?

Is it living? Yes
First Age? No
Is it good? No
Third Age? Yes
Man? Yes
4th age? No

2nd age? So it is said
Is it a man of Gondor? No

In light of the 2nd age answer, I reckon that next person here gets it! ;)

Is it a man of Rohan?

Isildur?

... or not
 

I would have thought that, given the combination of clues, there is only one possible answer. But there we are. :rolleyes:

Is it living? Yes
Is it good? No
Man? Yes
Is it a man of Gondor? No
First Age? No
2nd age? So it is said
Third Age? Yes
4th age? No

Is it a man of Rohan? No
Isildur? No

Valandil?

Valandil? Which one?

Valandil, the son of Isildur.

No one got it yet?
 

Is it living? Yes
Is it good? No
Man? Yes
Is it a man of Gondor? No
First Age? No
2nd age? So it is said
Third Age? Yes
4th age? No
Is it a man of Rohan? No
Isildur? No

Valandil, the son of Isildur. No (Actually, it's neither :D )

(Small hint: take a look at the second question/response down ;) )

One of Sharkey's men?

Is it living? Yes
Is it good? No
Man? Yes
Is it a man of Gondor? No
First Age? No
2nd age? So it is said
Third Age? Yes
4th age? No
Is it a man of Rohan? No
Isildur? No
Valandil, the son of Isildur. No

One of Sharkey's men? No

(Second small hint: take a look at the sixth question/response down. :p )

Is he of the Haradrim?