Isengard with Merry and Pippin. Even if the start is nasty, in the end there's food, drink and a cool wizard - whereas if I went with Frodo and Sam, all I got would be hunger, thirst, despair and missing fingers.

Would you rather be a Man in the First Age or an Elf in the Third?

Elf in the third

Whould you rather Hear verbal fights from Aragorn/Boromir or Boromir/Legolas

Boromir/Legolas. We hear a lot from Legolas/Gimli and Boromir/Aragorn, but not from Boromir/Legolas. It would be interesting to see how they pursuade each other.

Would you rather be Turin or Nienor (regardless of gender)?

Not sure who they are so i'll say turin

would u rather have an Orc or a Troll for a pet

They are brother and sister with a tragic fate. They appear in The Silmarillion, Children of Hurin, and Unfinished Tales.

Orc. They are easier to kill once they get too pesky.

Would you rather be saved by Gwaihir or Thorondor?

Gwaihar

Would u rather cry with Pippin or Boromir

Meaning?:confused:

If something sad happend....

Pippin, he would do something funny to cheer me up.

Would you rather live in Lake Town or Edoras?

Lake access property is always more valuable. That is, after Smaug does his final belly flop, of course. ;)

Would you rather be on the ship with Elendil sailing to the shores of Middle-earth, or on the ship with Frodo sailing to Valinor?

valinor

would u rather hug Aragorn or Legolas?

Aragorn. I prefer Men to Elves.

Would you rather bite off Beren's hand or Frodo's finger?

For future reference, it's more fun if you explain your answer briefly.

Which one of them are you?

;) :D

Beren's hand. I like wolves better than Gollums. So I'd rather be Carcharoth that ol' Stinker.

Would you rather be at the Long Expected Party or the Unexpected Party?

At the long expected party I think it would be cool to party with hobbits and Gandalf :D

Would you rather dance with Aragorn or Gandalf?

Aragorn. I don't see Gandalf as a dancing type.

Would you rather face a Nazgul or a Barrow-wight?

A nazgul so I can kick some baddie butt!

Would you rather die like Aragorn or like Boromir?

Hmm... both are rather interesting deaths. They both accept their death in the end, but Aragorn dies peacefully and Boromir in a fight. Boromir also has a redemption moment in his last breath...

I think Boromir, just because of the "romantic" point of view of dying in a battle.

Would you rather defend Helm's deep or Dunharrow in a battle?

Defend helms deep because i'd be with the best fighters!

Would you rather kiss an orc or Gollum?

I was actually Beren in a WW game some time ago, and Shastanis Tinúviel was my lover. But Frodo is one of my favourite characters.

I'd rather kiss an orc. Think of the taste of Gollum's 500-year-old mouth, especially after all that fish! Besides there's this really hot orc in one of the movies.

Would you rather be the Steward or the King?

The steward because I'd rather serve the King

would u rather fly on an eagle or a fell beast?

Rikae's game? And I just meant your siggie. That's not from the game.... is it?

An eagle. They would help me. The fell beasts, on the other hand, would bring me straiht to Sauron.

Would you rather be Maedhros, Maglor, Celegorm, Caranthir, Curufin, Amrod, or Amras?

Amrod even though i don't know who s/he is.

Would you rather Boromir had the one ring or Aragorn?

Aragorn. He would give it back to Frodo on the first chance. We all know what Boromir would do. ;)

They are all sons of Feanor. First Age stuff.

Would you rather recieve a sack of lembas or a coil of elvish rope as a gift from Lorien?

Sack of lembas. OMNOMNOM! :D

Would you rather be Feanor or Frodo?

Feanor, because I wouldn't want to end my days in Middle Earth in melancholy.

Would you rather be Saruman or Radagast?

Yes that one. And I know you did but it just reminded me of being Beren. ;) The sig is not from the game because regardless of what might have happened in private, Shasta and I never publicly bit each other. I bit several Downers in Finlandmoot though.

I'd rather be Saruman because, well, I would be him rather than Radagast. I have this thing for power, you know... and for all the colours of the rainbow.

Would you rather wear Narya, Nenya or Vilya?

Nenya. You know, water. Even though I never understood that logic, Vilya has sapphire (blue = water) and Elrond commands Bruinen, so... But whatever.

During the days of the major final battles of the War of the Ring, would you prefer to be in Minas Tirith or Erebor?

Minas Tirith because my dwarven RPG character of nine years is going home and the new one will be a dashing young nobleman from Minas Tirith - which means that I'm head over heels for all things Gondorian at the moment. Silly reason I know.

Would you rather follow Fëanor, Fingolfin or Finarfin?

Fingolfin. Feanor is to Feanorish, and those who stayed in Aman may be wise but bo-oring.

Would you rather be Bilbo in the "There and Back Again" story, or Merry or Pippin's role in LOTR?

Bilbo, certainly. Every coherent argument I can put together for why it'd be better seems to apply equally to Merry and Pippin, but it just seems like Bilbo gets a generally happier ending.

Would you rather have to fight Fingolfin or Morgoth?

Morgoth. Why would I even want to fight Fingolfin? I'd rather do something crazy and noble.

Would you rather be a Vanya, Noldo, or Teler?

Have no ideal who/what these are but I'd choose Vanya.

would u rather sword fight with Aragorn or Boromir

Aragorn. No particular reason.

Would you rather stay with Bombadil or with Treebeard for a week?

Hmmmmn. I'd probably kill my good twin; his incessant singing might be nice for a few minutes, but it would get annoying fast. On the other hand, Treebeard . . . yeah, no real downsides there.

Would you rather have to tell Sauron you stole his ring or Feanor you stole a Silmaril?

To answer you, Bom, tell Sauron. It's no great news after all!

Would you rather live in Hobbiton or Bree? (I don't think this was asked before... was it?)

In hobbitton cause its peaceful

Would you rather sing with orcs or Aragorn

Aragorn, doubtless. He might even teach me some ann-thenath...

Would you rather visit ME for a few days in the beginning of the Second or the Fourth Age?

Possiable second age because thats when the fellowship's together right?

Would you rather prank Legolas or Gandalf

That was Third Age, but whatever :)

As for the question - definitely Gandalf! I mean, there is nothing fun about pranking Legolas - but with Gandalf, whoo, that must be exciting! I mean, dangerous and fun to see and try to expect his reactions! :smokin:

Would you rather have Denethor (the Steward) or Thingol as your boss?

Thingol, definitely.

Would you rather be a King of Men or an average Elf?