I didn't address it because I conceded the point. But that wasn't my only point against him, so my case is not destroyed. And how do you know I "barking up the wrong tree?" Have you considered that I might be right? You seem to be assuming my innocense- a dangerous thing to do in this game.

But Ang, do admit, Roa's right about one thing: Boro is being oddly defensive...

Analysis and summaries aren't the same thing, Roa. Once again, not a contradiction. Beginning to be quite suspicious on my list there. If you're not a penguin, you might be a shoemaker, but I'm less and less sure of your innocence.

In fact,

--phantom
++Roa

Given the extreme frailty of the evidence against him, yes, it's quite odd he's bothering to defend himself at all...

It seems I got myself overly fussed about the deadline. Is it a bit later than our 10:00? [Finnish, perchance?] I now rather wish I'd voted for Diamond.

I'm sorry if defending myself means calling people out when they twist around and talk about contradictions that aren't even there.

And Roa I repeat I never said anything about being against analysis. I said I find no points in summaries, summary is not an analysis. Please stop making it look like I said anything wrong about analysis, because that's what everyone does. The fact is you have taken my words out of context and twisted them. Somehow you claim "you're my top suspect" when I said Lalaith concerned me the most.

Roa's acts are strange but it actually in a wierd way makes her look more innocent to me. She's just being far too aggressive, and this makes me think Lalaith is behind all this. Lalaith, you've been nudging suspicion towards me all day hoping someone would bite. Roa seems more like a lost innocent than a bandwagoning penguin.

++Lalaith

Roa I don't like your comment hereI think saying this is just as dangerous. You seem to be quite defensive today of all days, why? I know you usually bicker with other players over stuff (which is fine) but like I said today? you are making yourself seem more and more suspisious.

double double toil and trouble
 

How does questioning your analysis assume your innocence? Is this a bit of a slip?

I'm afraid I don't have time to stick around.

++Boromir

Maybe I'm just being stubborn, but he doesn't sit right with me. Notice, also, Ang, that he's ignored the point of two accusations, and instead confuses the matter at hand. I honestly don't know if it's deliberate, but Boromir's too smart for it not to be.

Something I posted has had vast psychological repurcussions among the more easily led players? Score!

Now, there's seems to be a debate going on about the differences between theories and baseless arguments, not to mention the difference between summaries and analysis.

For my part, I doin't have concrete feelings towards posting reviews of others' posts. I've toyed with a few different ways of going about it in my short WW career. I think, at the moment, my preferred way of doing it is waiting until we have some actual deaths or proven identities to go on, and then analyzing players that ping us wrong. I mean, I feel like reviewing someone's posting history is a lot more worthwhile after we have some known facts, the kind which only come about from lynchings, night deaths, seer reveals, and to a somewhat lesser extent, convincing Gifted proclimations. That's why all the analyzing and post reviewing has somewhat bored me today. I also prefer to just link to a post instead of summing it up, and then giving whatever impression I have of said post, with a possible quote if it seems necessary. This way, people get to read new stuff (ie my opinions) without having to slog through a recap of posts they already read -- and if they want to verify the exact post for themselves, well, there's a handy link.

But that's how I've taken to doing it. Obviously, others don't. I might not like reading over long summaries, but I'm not going to tell anyone to stop doing it because frankly they ain't gonna listen to me anyway.

Right now, I'm not sure what to think of all the arguing. To paraphrase the noble SpM, it's almost always the ones as look most fair that are most foul. So right now the high profile nickering of people like Ang, Roa, Boro, and Lal make them look a bit foul, depending on your viewpoint. Which worries me that, much like in Kath's game just now, provides ample room for the Weres to hide. Face it, if Lommy hadn't dreamt of her dad, he'd have made it to the end and lunched on the whole village, perhaps sacrificing Lhuna and Tom along the way, while everyone else was in a flurry to lunch tgwbs and Durelin et al.

The firepower in this struggle is unequal, against Lalaith , and I fear it profits none but the penguins. Are there any moderates out there willing to take a punt on Kitanna?

A modly voice from the heavens above...
 

The deadline is 10 PM GMT (not BST), which means that you have 48 minutes left.

No, you're still missing the point. You moved me onto your list of suspects for a post you said had nothing worth mentioning. That is the point. Your refusal to acknowledge this only makes you look worse to me.

He stated that I would be helpful if I focused elsewhere. If I were a were-penguin or a cobbler, I wouldn't be helpful at all. Therefore it seems that he is assuming I'm innocent.

Bollywogs. I have to leave and am not at all confident on who to vote for. Oy. But I have a job interview, and I can't be late for it.

+ + LALAITH

I don't know, there's been a lot of twisting words or perceived twisting of words going about, but some of the things she's said about other players hasn't sat well with me. I wish I had time to actually articulate this more. Also, I keep worrying that none of these high profile players today are guilty. But hopefully whatever happens with the lynching today and the death tonight will make things a little clearer.

++Anguirel
He's the only one I have even the slightest suspicions for. Even if my suspicions and reasons are weak, I'd rather vote for him instead of picking someone at random.

Oh Diamond, not again.

Vote count (curse these retractables, hope this is right)

Lalaith 4 (Enca, Firefoot, Boro, Diamond)
Boro 2 (Roa, Lalaith)
Kitanna 2 (Spawn, Anguirel)
Anguirel 1 (Kitanna)

Nine votes down, six to go? Am I right?

It's a he.
I followed two or three previous Games through or half through. (wereducks, dueling wizards e.g.)

By the by, to all, just call me Mac, please. One more Maclaure or Macaluare and I'm going to scream.


I'm happy the "theories"-discussion ceased. I think we all agree that we cannot do without theories, but that they have to be coherent. If they're not, and somebody will be there checking that, it will give its writer a sure rise on everyone's suspicion lists.


So, whom to vote for. I don't have a real suspect yet and considered to vote for somebody who has no votes yet and to abstain this way. But not voting is voting for the majority. I can't give good reasons for anybody, all I can say is that Kitanna to me feels worse than Lalaith.

++Kitanna

(edit: cross-posted with Lalaith)

Ah. I fear the battle is lost. Oh well, you lot had better be right and I wrong. An innocent Lalaith is a real asset, and if you've just gone and squandered it...

EDIT: I feel your pain, Macalaure. (Hee hee, I'm Maglor savvy enough to spell it right. He taught me to play the lute and flute back in Valinor, y'know. Excellent fellow, bet he's very sorry about the Kinslaying. Ahem.) I had a long period of being mistaken for a petite maiden called Anguriel...

ANOTHER EDIT: Ah. All is not lost.

Well I see no reason not to go with my gut on this one

++Anguirel

I think his push for Kitanna is odd and his remark about being the unwitting cobbler are also odd. Ang is a smart guy and I find his playing to be a little over zealous for the first day. This may change, but I doubt any thing could change my mind today.

Sigh. I didn't want to have to do this, but I must. There are only 3 votes left of which 2, Naria and Eonwe, are notorious no-shows.
An innocent Lalaith, might, as Ang so nicely says, be an asset to the village but a Seer Lalaith is definitely so.
Boro is a Werepenguin.
Are Eonwe or Naria around, if so, we can still vote for Boro if everyone who still can retracts. Please say so quickly.

Ranger, if we can save me from lynching, please protect me tonight.

Told you so. :p Great job, forcing the seer to reveal herself, guys. Nice try to save her, though, Ang.

We forgot to mention it, but as usual, if there's a tie, the first one to get most votes will be lynched.

Lalaith can still be saved.

Argh, where is everybody?

Ah. To quote from one of the finest Werewolf players, in my view, to grace these boards:

wibble

I bid you goodnight. Well done Lalaith, and I hope you can be rescued yet.

Kitanna, I would rather, obviously, save myself by lynching Boro than by lynching you. If you are around and are in a position to retract your vote, please announce yourself now.

I want to be sure you survive regardless of where the votes go. If that means I have to vote for myself then damnit, I'll vote for myself.

Well ok then I retract

--Anguirel

++Boromir88

You tricksey!!!!

Good job Seer! If your wrong though I say you be the shoe maker.

We have ten minutes. Kitanna, hold off for five minutes.

There are three voters left, and several retractions can be made- however, if no one shows by dealine, I'm retracting my vote to vote for kitanna, and Kitanna, I hope you vote for yourself to save her.

Leaders:

Kitanna 3
Lalaith 4
Boromir 3

We need two more votes for Boromir

I have had a little bit of time to read through everything and their seems to be a lot of bickering back and forth between a few people and yes I find that quite odd for the first Day. The only one that stood out for me however was


++Lalaith

Ugh....I honestly don't know(Day ones really suck). I feel I need to put someone down rather than no one. Well the deadline is fast approaching so I doubt this vote will change. I hope to have more time(unexpected RL stuff came up today) the next Day to help.

I seriously didn't want to do this, but if you don't vote for Boromir then Lalaith will die tonight. I'm the ranger and if you lynch me Roa then Lalaith isn't going to survive.

Alright.

--Kitanna

++Boromir88

He played the "I've been lynched first the last game"-card. Only a penguin would do that. :p

If Boro turns out to not be a penguin, Lalaith is going to be very dead by the end of next day.

Ah, you're around still too Roa. Good. Hold off awhile. I will wait til just before deadline and if I have to, I will also retract to Kitanna.
Sorry Kit.

Well, that just sucks then. Nevermind. NAria- what are you doing?

Naria!!!!! Nooooo!!!!!

Did Naria really just do that? Where's the phantom, by the way?

Oh Lord. This is a shambles.

Naria- even if you doubt Lalaith's claim, we can test it by lynching Boromir. If he's a wolf, she's slightly more trustworthy, if not, then we know she's a wolf. If you let he seer die, then we know what you are.

_ _ Lalaith

++ Boromir88

Sorry soooo sorry......I cross posted with like alot of everyone!!!! HOLY CLAP this is close