Haha! :D

SATH

and now I'd like to see the R's

SHRAT

how about L ?

TRASHL

forgot an a

"e"s, please.

TRASHLE

Hm, I figured nearly everything out .
( -a-e -- a --s-- for heart's ache,
for heart's despair, and for heart's dread,
for light gone dark and laughter dead. ) But I still am not able to find it! Argh!!

M perhaps ?

Very good choice!

TRASHLEM

Well, in that case I guess it must be:
But I still don't know who said it. Perhaps Morgoth?? :rolleyes:

*Off to search the books once more*

Correct!

It's Lúthien to Daeron while she is imprisoned on Hírilorn.

:) I just hurried here to tell you that I have finally found it!

But it is not while Luthien is imprisoned on Hirilorn (that's where I had looked for it before and why I couldn't find it!)
She says this to Daeron right after Melian told her that Beren was in a dungeon, and after that she asks Daeron to help her go and find Beren, and Daeron betrays her to Thingol.

Well, anyway, here is a new one, (this time not from the lays of Beleriand)

ups
 

A's?

A

I's?

Ai

"-a---/ ---/ ------_-i---/!" (......) "--i-/ -a-/ ---------/ --a--/ a--/, ----/ -i--/, I/ -i--'-/ --i--/ I/ ------/ ----/ ---/ ----/ a-ai-/. ---/ I/ ----/ --/ ---i--/."

N's?

AIN

"-a---/ ---/ ---n--_-i---/!" (......) "--i-/ -a-/ ----n---n/ --a--/ a--/, ----/ -i--/, I/ -i-n'-/ --in-/ I/ ------/ ----/ ---/ ----/ a-ain/. ---/ I/ ----/ -n/ ---in-/."

S's?

AINS

"-a---/ ---/ ---n--_-i---/!" (......) "--is/ -a-/ s---n---n/ --a-s/ a--/, --s-/ -i--/, I/ -i-n'-/ --in-/ I/ s-----/ ----/ s--/ ----/ a-ain/. ---/ I/ ----/ -n/ ---in-/."

G's?

"t"s?

GIANTS

"-a---/ t--/ t--nt-_-i-t-/!" (......) "T-is/ -a-/ s---nt--n/ --a-s/ ag-/, --s-/ -i--/, I/ -i-n't/ t-in-/ I/ s-----/ ----/ s--/ t---/ again/. --t/ I/ ---t/ -n/ ---ing/."

L's?

LASTING

"-a---/ t--/ t--nt-_-i-t-/!" (......) "T-is/ -a-/ s---nt--n/ --a-s/ ag-/, --s-/ -i--/, I/ -i-n't/ t-in-/ I/ s---l-/ ----/ s--/ t---/ again/. --t/ I/ ---t/ -n/ ---ing/."

After this vastly successful L, I take a Y. :p

A STYLING

"-a---/ t--/ t--nty_-i-t-/!" (......) "T-is/ -ay/ s---nt--n/ y-a-s/ ag-/, --s-/ -i--/, I/ -i-n't/ t-in-/ I/ s---l-/ ----/ s--/ t---/ again/. --t/ I/ ---t/ -n/ ---ing/."

D's?

DYING LAST


"-a---/ t--/ t--nty_-i-t-/!" (......) "T-is/ day/ s---nt--n/ y-a-s/ ag-/, --s-/ -i--/, I/ didn't/ t-in-/ I/ s---ld/ ----/ s--/ t---/ again/. --t/ I/ ---t/ -n/ ---ing/."

"e"s?

H's?

Good choices! :)

"-a--h/ the/ t-enty_-i-th/!" (......) "This/ day/ se-enteen/ yea-s/ ag-/, --se/ -i-e/, I/ didn't/ thin-/ I/ sh--ld/ e-e-/ see/ thee/ again/. --t/ I/ -e-t/ -n/ h--ing/."

--se/ -i-e/....
 

I think I know where I would have to look for it, but it's in a volume I don't have.

so, R's?

"-ar-h/ the/ t-enty_-i-th/!" (......) "This/ day/ se-enteen/ years/ ag-/, R-se/ -i-e/, I/ didn't/ thin-/ I/ sh--ld/ e-er/ see/ thee/ again/. --t/ I/ -e-t/ -n/ h--ing/."

Oh, I'm sorry, Macalaure! :o (It's in Volume 9.) But I think you're on the right track. :)

No need to be sorry.

There's only one word I don't know... M?

"Mar-h/ the/ t-enty_-i-th/!" (......) "This/ day/ se-enteen/ years/ ag-/, R-se/ -i-e/, I/ didn't/ thin-/ I/ sh--ld/ e-er/ see/ thee/ again/. --t/ I/ -e-t/ -n/ h--ing/."

a W, maybe?

"Mar-h/ the/ twenty_-i-th/!" (......) "This/ day/ se-enteen/ years/ ag-/, R-se/ wi-e/, I/ didn't/ thin-/ I/ sh--ld/ e-er/ see/ thee/ again/. --t/ I/ -e-t/ -n/ h--ing/."

Too good a chance to pass to up ask for a little requested letter.
"x"s?