Okay... but what I mean is that once I answered them, Brinniel basically said, "yeah, well, I don't care, I still want to lynch you just in case," and yet now her defence of her highly suspicious voting apparently rests on her being so convinced I was a wolf that nothing else mattered except to get me.

The other thing I am still quite bitter about is this: Brinn's main case against me is that I was "wishy-washy" on Glirdan– because I didn't go all out against him from the word go– when in fact I think I played in notable part in getting him lynched. (And Nog also, not to mention having some credit for Sally.) Meanwhile, I documented how she was not only "wishy-washy", but actually tried to discourage us from lynching him. And everyone ignored this, nodded their heads and said, "Oh, yes, Nerwen is wishy-washy, and Brinn is oh so helpful and wise. And Nerwen's wolf-voting-record is just too good to be true, while Brinn's just goes to prove how helpful and wise she is."

EDIT:X'd with 2 Lommys.

I just realized, she probably picked Brinn as the Unicorn by elimination. Think about it– it couldn't be Shasta because he thought it was Morsul, it couldn't be you because you were urging the unicorn to reveal, it couldn't be me because I'm too reluctant to die, and clearly it couldn't possibly be Lommy. ;)


It's just numbers, Lommy. If both wolves had survived yesterDay, it would now be 2 wolves to 4 innocents. That's worth taking a bit of risk for.

So... seems I'm talking to myself here...

If it isn't Brinn, who can it be? There's only Shasta and Agan left.

If it's Shasta, we must suppose that Wolftanis Althreduin carefully faked a wllingness to vote Legate while "reluctantly" settling for Agan, then left with a vague promise of maybe switching later. A perfect way for a wolf to avoid possible responsibility for the lynch of an innocent, while making himself look good if his comrade got lynched, and all this without endangering said comrade. Brilliant!

...And then he returned, flipped out and stabbed Legwolf in the back for no particular reason. Um... yeah... whatever... Now if it it had been Boro or the phantom in Legate's place, I could just see that happening.:p

If it's Agan, then Legwolf decided it was so likely one of them was going to be lynched, or alternatively so unlikely that Agan would that he thought he might as well go wolf-on-wolf, even though at that point it looked like I was going to get plenty of votes. This is just possible, but it requires very poor judgement from Legate. However, if by any chance the wolf isn't Brinn, then Agan's the only one left (yes, from my point of view).

Still no-one here.

Well, I just want to say then– I really can't see any reason not to vote Brinniel. It would put my mind at rest.:p

The only thing I'm waiting for is to see what Lottie has to say in Brinn's defence, and why she's being so mysterious about it. My guess, though, is that the Unicorn Theory will turn out to be right.

Two hours later...

Here, have skimmed, will post momentarily. I will say I'm willing to believe Lommy - everyone has posted and no one's countered her claim of being the Unicorn (even though she forgot her role :rolleyes:), which narrows the wolf down to one of three (from my point of view, obviously) - Agan, Nerwen, and Brinniel.

Hahahaha! :D

Just noting that I did it too. It were only the recent turns of events and the fact that I started to suspect Brinn that made me consider you more innocent, and even now you're my second candidate.

I have a feeling I should do something useful but I'm lazy, so first I'm going to prime a canvas.

I went back and looked at the last-minute voting yesterday, and Brinn didn't say she X'ed with anyone (so I'm assuming she didn't), so the issue I'm having is why wouldn't a Brinnwolf jump on the Legate-wagon after his fate had already been sealed? I'm assuming that she saw Nerwen's vote, winty's vote, and my vote, which put Legate at four votes.

Could this be why? Brinn defends her vote here before anyone (besides Nerwen even mentions it in a negative context, and immediately tries to set up today's lynch ("a potential candidate I suspect more"). And here -

I think it's possible Brinn wouldn't have voted Legate because she expected precisely what Nerwen would say... but I'm not sure how likely it is.

Nerwen, you, and Legate were on the chopping block yesterday, so Nerwen didn't have a lot of choices if she wanted to save herself, but on the whole I tend to agree with this comment (also based on what I've read today so far).

My personal take on the winty-kill was that no one (but me :p) suspected him.

Bah... I can't tell if this post is frustrated innocent Nerwen or "that move was so stupid I'd never have done it as a wolf please believe me" Nerwolf.

Alright, this post bothers me. It looks like Brinn has decided that Nerwen is 100% a wolf... and it's nigh-impossible to be 100% in this game. Plus it looks "grasping at straws"-ish... I'm not sure what the actual term is, but it's like "twisting the facts to fit the theory" kind of thing.

#988 sounds like frustrated innocent Nerwen again... but Sally already swayed me once this game with the same attitude.

This is actually a pretty good point.

I actually tend to agree with this as well - I remember thinking "I don't really like the tone of this post" the first time I read it.

Hi! Can I touch your horn?

Hah, Agan thinks what I do.

I think the thing about Brinn is more likely at this point, but that's an interesting take on Agan, too.


Alright, a list from most to least suspicious (discounting myself, Lottie, and Lommy)

Brinniel
Nerwen
Aganzir - Shockingly enough, she's a little bit under my radar ("Impossible!") I need to change that.

Jeez, haven't I left that behind me yet? :p

Okay, I have reread, and I have to say I'm still confused grr... Basically, it could be any of Brinn, Nerwen or Agan, but I think I'm letting Agan be, for toDay at least. If she was a wolf, I don't think she'd have killed Winty, or more like, she wouldn't have needed to. What I mean by that is that for Nerwen Winty would've been a safe choice who would lead no suspicion tracks to her, and for Brinn, it wouldn't be a loss of a supporter or anyone who can go after Nerwen recklessly.

Gggg. I think the recent evidence points a bit more to Brinn's direction, but then again, somehow it's easier to imagine a wolf-Nerwen getting four fellows lynched than a Brinn-wolf getting three fellows lynched and trying to save the last one.

But two questions: 1. Would Brinn look any better if her last-minute vote had been for Legate? No, and that's why I think we shouldn't use her vote as an argument against her, or at least do that with caution. 2. Would a Nerwolf have thrown fellow Legate under the bus instead of getting herself lynched and him as someone less suspected continue the game for the evil team? Yes, if that was what she needed to do to keep consistent (if Nerwolf had self-sacrificed for Legate and thus looked inconsistent, it would've been pretty condemning against him and the end for the evil team). But would a Nerwolf have expressed suspicion of fellow Legate so early on during the Day? Not sure...

Stop right there. You cannot know what kind of player I am, only I can know that. And yes, I have in fact pursued someone strongly before due to gut-feeling. Sometimes I am spot on and other times I'm very much mislead.

I didn't "know" anyone's innocence (Morsul or Mira) as you keep repeating. Did you ever go back and think that I was perhaps the only one being logical at the time? C'mon, I know an easy lynch when I see it.

One thing: You believe that me going so forcefully after you and the idea that I seem so sure of your guilt makes me look wolfish. Yet, whenever I admit I could be wrong, that's also suspicious. So what am I supposed to say that isn't wolfish to you, huh?

Btw, it's rather hypocritical for you to accuse me of being wolfish for going after you so strongly and seeming convinced of your guilt considering you're doing the exact same thing to me.

Look, I am not sure of your guilt, and there's no way I could be sure except in the event of your death. And I'm sorry if you are actually innocent, because that means this is just an innocent-on-innocent thing happening between us and we're basically letting the wolf sit back and win without even having to do much work.

Glad to have you as our unicorn, though I must admit I was hoping it would be one of the other three unknowns since you were already pretty much innocent in my book.

I did defend my vote because Nerwen tried to spin it as though I was "saving" Legate, which she knows is a lie. And of course I would set her up for toDay's lynch...she's only been my top suspect for half the game...


Okay people, I can understand why you could be suspicious of me, but if you choose to lynch me over Nerwen who I've been trying to lynch for four Days and she turns out to be the wolf, I will be so disgusted and you will NEVER hear the end of it. For the sake of my sanity, please can we just lynch her toDay and if I'm wrong about her then feel free to lynch me all you want toMorrow...even though it would result in a village loss, I'd probably deserve it for being so stuck on Nerwen this long. I think I'd actually rather be blamed for a village loss than get off-ed thanks to a wolf who though I insisted all along was evil, manages to convince the entire village that I'm the wolf.

Gah, I so do not have the time to deal with this. There's so much schoolwork I must get done, yet I just know I'm just going to spent the rest of the evening on WW. If I were wise, I would've never joined this game, but I so wanted to play...and honestly I didn't think I was going to last this long. If I were assigned a wolf role, I'm quite certain I would've dropped out before the game even began. I have to run to class now and then a meeting, but I'll be back in around 3 1/2 hours.

Okay, I've been through Agan's posts since Legate was turned, and... eh. Her posts look like typical Agan, and... while there's more evidence against both Nerwen and Brinn, I can't help thinking there's something weird about the sheer lack of anything against Agan. :p My opinion of her pretty much stands at this point.

It's not really her vote that made me suspicious of her but the fact that everybody else whose role I don't know suspected Legate. I mean, it made more sense for the wolf pack to try to stay alive yesterday, the both of them, and Brinn and Legate treated each other in a way convenient for two wolves.

I doubt it, but my argument lies entirely on the fact that I think neither of the wolves wanted to get lynched yesterday, even to make the other look better. Of course I might be wrong and they might have had a different approach, but my logic tells me Brinn looks worse than Nerwen.

If it's of any comfort to you, Nerwen hasn't convinced me. I reached the conclusion on my own, based on your actions. And if we lynch you today and you are innocent, you can take my word that I'll try to lynch Nerwen tomorrow (unless Shasta suddenly jumps up and cries "I'm a wolf!").

Haha poor Shasta! :p

I read through Legate's posts from both the day before he was turned and the days after that but they didn't really help me... Ie they didn't scream "Lookie lookie she's my fellow!!!!"

++Brinniel

It's either she or Nerwen (or Shasta but in that case I'll be angry with him) and I think we have better chances with Brinn.

Leaving soonish. Night bunnies (hopefully just in RL :p).

You know what's frustrating is this reminds me perfectly of Nogrod's game from late 2007 where Agan set up this huge case against me, which resulted in the entire village blindly following. At the time, I was in fact screaming to the village, "You are falling into a trap. This is what the wolves want." But no one listened, and we lost.

With Nerwen driving this late bandwagon, that's what concerns me most about her. Though since it isn't actually the last Day like it was in the other game (when a double lynch occurred), it could be quite easy for a wolf to tag along in a bandwagon, and be able to survive due to there being more "obvious" suspects around. Which is why I'm also worried about Aganzir. Lynch me now, and I could see Nerwen very well getting lynched toMorrow, but if I'm wrong about her, then we've lost the game. I'm feeling quite certain it has to be one of these two. And if it's you, Shasta, then well, you probably deserve that win.

I guess what personally makes it so devastating about me getting lynched is that I know from previous games the village has lost every time they've decided to lynch me as an innocent. So right now, I'm not very optimistic about winning. Which is a shame, since we were so close.

Btw, I will be around for another half hour because my teacher basically excused us from class (again). Once again, I find myself wasting time here rather than doing more important schoolwork. All the things I have done for this village...and look how you repay me. :mad: Right now I really hope I'm right about Nerwen mainly because when this game is over I want you all to be able to hang your heads in shame and apologise to me profusely. :p I also realise if I'm wrong about her, I'll probably be eating my own words.

Ugh. I'd really have preferred to die earlier - I had wonderful track record, I could honestly say I suspected all the wolves but now I'm totally lost. I so wish we could have three lynches... Brinn's latest posts look rather innocent, but I know she'd be able to write all that as a wolf. I'm increasingly worried about Agan, she seems so easy and confident. Quite honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if she actually was our last wolf... And it's getting late here and I should vote... grh. Given that Legate is in the same apartment, I could ask him to give the name of his fellow for having spent most of his game as an innocent he would probably mentally be on our side after his death. :Merisu: Seriously though, I guess I just have to vote. For the first time in this game, I'm happy I won't be around when the actual decision about the lynch (ie majority of the votes) is being made...:rolleyes:

It makes sense Brinn is the last wolf because she wasn't at Legate's throat and for her it would've been beneficial to keep Lottie alive.

It makes sense Nerwen is the last wolf because she really seriously has been thinking too much from the wolf pow - all the explanations of Night kills and now this who could be the Unicorn stuff.

It makes sense Agan is the last wolf because then there hasn't been a huge scale wolf-on-wolf massacre and because she seems so carefree now.

AARGH.

This:

Proves me wrong. :p

I did indeed.

Actually, I thought she was the Uni ever since Morsul's death. She was very much against killing the Uni just 'cause, and seemed sure that he was no wolf/Uni. I thought that indicated that she was the Uni herself. Also, toDay she had thought a lot about the Uni and looked at both sides...anyway. I was wrong. :rolleyes:

And now that I'm not waiting for the reveal, she does looks suspicious.

Lottie and Shasta, are you around? Who do you suspect?

I also realised Agan could be simply carefree because Lottie and I are known innocents, it's pretty obvious Shasta is innocent and there are two Days, just enough to lynch the unknowns from her pow... :rolleyes:

I'm trying to comfort myself by maths: there is a 66,66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666 66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666 66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666 66...% chance we win this game...


edit: xed with Lottie

I'm here, but to be honest, my suspicions haven't changed since I posted last. :confused:

Also, Lommy, if that's really supposed to be a comma then you're awfully confident. :p

I've become increasingly worried about her too and while Nerwen remains my top suspect, it's been itching at me that I could very well be wrong. I hate being wrong, which is why I want Nerwen to be the wolf, but if we end up losing because Nerwen and I are stuck on some innocent-on-innocent bickering and allow the real wolf to slide easily to victory, then that's really going to burn come end-game. While I'd say Nerwen remains my first choice, I'd be satisfied with lynching Aganzir too...and I'd definitely rather see her lynched over myself.

I have to run to a meeting now, but I should be back in a little over an hour.

Commas are decimals in Europe.

And those odds will be much smaller if you lynch me. :rolleyes:

I didn't know that! :eek:

I do like the idea of a sixty-six thousand-percent chance of winning, though. :smokin:

Lynch who you will, I don't really have a preference, but my vote goes to

++Nerwen

I'm not convinced she's our last wolf, not at all, but if she turns out to be it, I feel better if I haven't given up my suspicion of her at the last minute. ;)

Also, she and Agan have to ready answers for everything. But Brinniel is too unsure, on the other hand... garrrr. Why have Agan and Nerwen dropped all mutual suspicion and allied against Brinn? Is that innocent or is one of them desperate to seek allies?

Bah, I'm going to leave this to your hands for now. If there is a toMorrow, I will think (even) harder then.

PS. You should have let us lynch Nerwen instead of Morsul (or Mira) and this would be a thousand times easier now! :mad:;)
PPS. Sorry Shasta, I forgot that in English you use a full stop instead of a comma there... I wish I was so certain, though!


edit: xed with Brinn & Shasta = cute dialogue!

I know, right? :rolleyes:

You have no idea how badly I want Nerwen to be evil; I don't like it when I'm wrong and if I am, I'll probably end up brain damaged from so much headdesking. On the bright side, at least I'll know that Aganzir is our culprit come toMorrow.

It'd be rather funny if Shasta actually ends up being the wolf...because I don't think any of us girls would expect that.

Alright, I'm going to a friend's concert and I'm not sure if I'll be back before DL, so...

++Brinniel

Ah, looking for an alternative candidate, are we?:p


Well, I juust wanted to make absolutely sure before voting–


++Brinniel

EDIT:X'd since Lommy.

Of course, because any other candidate is better than myself because I know I'm innocent. For me, it's 50/50 between you and Agan as a wolf. What, would expect me to vote myself? :rolleyes:

Maybe I will, because I don't want to be a part of this anymore. This is getting to be really stupid.

And it's funny you seem 100% certain I'm the wolf (and you suspect me for being 100% sure you're a wolf...even though that's not true)...so either you are a wolf happily on a lynchfest, or you're going to be very sorry come deadline.

Btw, do you not even think it's the slightest bit possible this may be innocent-on-innocent suspicion? Because you see, that's what I'm worried about...and if you aren't a wolf, we'll probably lose toMorrow.

That is a terrible reason to vote someone at this point, Lommy.

Because the recent voting makes Agan look much less suspicious than Brinn. You choose to dismiss that as evidence, so what can I say?

Now, if Brinn were to turn out innocent, I'd have to conclude either Agan or Shasta was a wolf despite appearances, and in that case, as I said, I think it would be Agan. But let's cross that bridge when and if we come to it.

No, you'd now be finding one or both of them "terribly suspicious", and mourning the fact that you went and killed me.

EDIT:X'd with Brinniel.
EDIT2:typo.

Of course, but I can't recall you suspecting her before, that's all.

No, I've explained this already. The point is that your "certainty" about me is what you're using to explain your suspect voting. I've already said what's wrong with the logic there. And no, I'm not 100% sure you're a wolf, but it does seem very likely.


And if you're innocent, it will, quite frankly, be your fault.

Neither of them were ever suspicious, and I feel like you guys have to be blind to think that because I don't understand how they ever were. If you were lynched Days ago and turned out innocent, then I would be most certainly looking for an Agan lynch toDay.

Okay, now this just really irks me. How the hell would you guys lynching me and the village losing because of it be MY fault?

You know what? Fine. You want the village loss to be MY fault? Then there you go:

++Brinn

Sorry, but saying that just puts me over the edge. I'm fed up enough that I'm not sure I want to be a part of this village anyway. I'm sure our wolf is gloating now. It's going to be awfully lame when we lynched so many wolves so early and still lose the game.

For voting suspiciously, and for literally driving an innocent– me– to lynch you. I was perfectly fair in my analyses of you, whereas you targeted me for Days on feeble grounds. (Technically, it would be Agan's fault too, but in this scenario I guess she'd be the wolf.)

You do realise that with the suspicion against me that you and Agan have cultivated, I'd probably be forced to lynch you now in self-defence even if I didn't particularly suspect you? (I do, but I'm just saying.)

So, if you're innocent, Brinn, then you've been the dupe of a wolf and you've probably– after a brilliant start– lost us the game through sheer stubbornness.

It doesn't seem like you, though.

EDIT:X'd with Brinn.

In fact you've already made the same point about yourself:

#1010

Voting suspiciously? All my voting has been spot on up until you, and there still is no proof that I am wrong in voting you. Don't forget I refused to take part in two stupid lynches. And even if you were lynched then instead and innocent, those were two different lynches, thus in my opinion, two Days lost for finding a more reasonable candidate. I still believe that if Morsul and Mira hadn't been lynched, then we would've won by now. Again you think my reasons for suspecting you are poor, but I believe them perfectly valid. Unless you are a wolf, you were never driven to vote me. You seemed pretty ready to lynch me within the first minutes of toDay before there was any sign you would be a serious lynch candidate for the Day. So if you are innocent, don't you dare put the blame on me.

Okay, this made me laugh. ;)

Basically this is to say I'm here and haven't much to say. :rolleyes:

EDIT: xed with Brinn

Okay, call it my fault then, but once you find out that I am innocent, it will be equally you're fault too.

*raises hand* May I make a suggestion? Let's blame the wolves if we lose...just sayin'.

Also maybe Morsul, but that one doesn't really have a reason. :p

Btw, I never said I deserved the blame, just that I deserved to be lynched. But the village loss would still be at the fault of those who would choose to lynch me.

If I vote myself again, can you just kill me off now and put me out of my misery?