Um...ok.

One of two twice - He is really Boromir II?
Protector of Two - Protected Merry and Pippin
Taker of three - he took Aragorn and legolas with him somewhere?
And one of nine - one of the fellowship, which had nine people


I have no idea for taker of three!

eh well go ahead but ill explain

one of two twice- one of two sons... one of two men in the fellowship
taker of three-he was shot with three arrows
proector-you got this right
and on of nine-easily right

oh! D'oh! I shoud have known! Oh well!


Here's the next one:

The brave
The departer
The challenger
The failed
The betrayed
The burned

Faramir

He was brave
He departed from Minas Tirith to guard Ithilien
Challenged the orcs that overan Osgiliath
Failed to Win
betrayed by Denetor
Burned by denetor

Nope, although that's a good guess.

Gandalf

Brave yeah he was
Departed for Valinor in the end
Challenged a Balrog
Failed to see the dangers of the ring earlier
Betrayed by Saruman
Are you telling me while fight a giant Fire monster he didnt get burned! actually cant think of one for this

Negatory!

maedhros

How about Denethor?

Nope. Gil-Galad was close. Here's a hint: They're all one, but each is seperate!

uing my friends psycic ability I will make him guess for me

he says Eomer so I will say Eomer(my friend knows nothing so this is wrong)

Nope!

Denetor

Nope.

Turin?

No sir!

Melkor? maybe even Feanor? or Finwe?

It's not Morgoth. As for Feanor and Finwe, it's not the right answer, but it's right! Think about it!

I think your toying around with me...

No! Figure it out! They're all right, but not the right answer! Solve my riddle!

could even be the Noldor

The brave-most of the princes
The departer-Kin-Stryfe
The challenger-Fingolfin
The failed-Noldor for retreiving all silmarils
The betrayed- feanor and fingolfin
The burned-all i can think of is the burning of the boats

No! Think! Finwe was correct! Feanor was correct! Ok, you're still not getting it, so here's a large hint. 6 DIFFERENT QUESTIONS!

Your COnfusing me now...

i think i get the clue but i dont know the answer...Gil there are six answers...Im assuming theyre part of a family or something

Yes! Now you're getting it!

SoF then?

The brave
The departer
The challenger
The failed
The betrayed
The burned

i can't think right now but they'll fit in

so Gil I just helped you i dont know the answer so its up to you

The brave-Finwe
The departer-FInarfin
The challenger-
The failed-feanor
The betrayed-Fingolfin
The burned-

not sure about rest...i'm thinking finwe and Co.

No, not the sons of Feanor! What do Finwe and Feanor have in common, besides the fact that they were related.

Gil-Galad! You are really, really close! Do you know what you're doing? There's six! You're so close, but they aren't in order!

The brave-Finwe
The departer-Feanor
The challenger-Fingolfin
The failed-Finarfin
The betrayed
The burned


not sure about rest...i'm trying to put them in order

No no no! It's in order, except for Finarfin! He's not in there! Now what do those people have in common! What were they all?

they were all high elves is it "the high elves?

They were Noldor?

Not just High Elves! Take it a step further. What's their title?

Eldar?

FIrst Born?

No! What are they? What are they all. Not about race, or division. What makes them different then every other Noldor. What responcibility to they have?

I didn't want to say this because it is probably too obvious, but they were all High Kings of the Noldor?

YES! FINALLY! YES, IT IS OBVIOUS! THEY ARE ALL HIGH KINGS OF THE NOLDOR. THE ANSWER IS, HIGH KING OF THE NORDOR!

The brave - Finwe - He alone faced Morgoth
The departer - Feanor - Departed Aman
The challenger - Fingolfin - Challenged Morgoth
The failed - Fingon - His attempt to win the Nirnaeth Arnoediad failed
The betrayed - Turgon - betrayed by Maeglin
The burned - Gil-Galad - Sauron grabbed him, and burned him



It was that simple! Congragulations Fingolfin! Truly! Your go!