Why? I like known innocents personally. Particularly ones the wolves are too scared to kill.

The fact that Sally just dropped this and apparently left without saying who her pick is does make me think she's more likely to be a wolf, at least. :rolleyes: Still, really don't want to take the risk that she might be hunting me, since I've been at the top of her list for Days now.

If we want to lynch somebody other than Sally, then who?

What do you mean? Makes perfect sense.

If Wolves learn about a known Hunter, then every time they have chance to kill them, there's the risk that one of them will be pulled to the grave along. But in numbers, a Hunter is just one innocent. A known innocent for the WWs but not-entirely-known for the village! And the WWs can pick any other victim to kill every Night. They have like over a dozen others to pick from!

If sally doesn't tell us NOW who she's hunting, I may vote her, seriously.

I don't want to vote Zil precisely because he's offered himself.

Yeah, but listen. If we lynch anyone else, there's a chance they're just an ordo. With Sally, it's either a wolf or the hunter, who is the innocent losing whom can be a good thing for us. Unlike losing an ordo. Think it through. (I guess if you ignore how suspicious Sally is and that a real hunter would really consider before revealing it boils down to whether you want to take your chances with one extra person dying who might or might not be a wolf.)


edit: again xed, now I will breathe deep and catch up :D

I don't like the idea of a last minute panic bandwaggon.

I don't like the idea of a last minute everybody-votes-everybody chaos.

I don't like any of this!

Salllllly!!!
Tell us!!!

And if sally hits an innocent we're down to innocents.

I could vote Eonwe, Inzil, Brinn or Lottie without feeling too bad. Though right now I am inclined to have Lottie at the bottom of that list because of her vote (if not for that vote she would probably be at the top).

For me, it's still between Zil and Sally. I would like to know who she's hunting though.

Unless we lynch the hunter who hunts an ordo, and then we're just down two innocents. And since she's been suspecting me and Pitch, and I know I'm innocent and Pitch is one of the people I trust the most right now, I really don't want to let her just kill one of us.

Concur.

And panic-wagon caused by the claimed hunter who promptly disappeared.

Just saying that Sally had the RL commitment and whatnot, but she clearly had enough time on her hands after her reveal to still post noncommital posts. And now silence. Nope. I'm voting her.

Exactly.

Lowkey really annoyed about this. Sally, I swear, if you are the hunter and you just didn't tell us who you're hunting, gonna be mad.

I guess I don't see this as an actual problem for the village, at least not now (I accept that if a wolf does a counter-reveal in the closing stages of a game it might get messy, but that is it).

I completely agree that Sally has been acting odd with this reveal, but I think we have too much to loose by voting for her.

There would come a point where we'd QT Sally as the last possible wolf. But I'm more inclined to think she's a wolf the longer she goes without posting, so I'm more fine with QTing her, I guess. If she answers, it could be a lie anyway.

You personally like known innocents, I personally like dead wolves, and I'm willing to take risks to get them.

Hear, hear. See how some of you were suspecting Kit because she didn't die the second she made a rangerish comment. What do you honestly imagine would happen with Sally?

oh holy :eek::eek::eek: I just looked at clock!!!!

Let's take the Sally chance, no weird last minute things please!!!


edit: xed with a million people again

Unless it's a last-minute bandwaggon against Greenie. That I could live with. :p

My gut feels very strongly against lynching Inzil. Same with Boro, to be honest, to stick with my own list of suspects.

Lhuna perhaps?

Why would she, though? Why is it any likely that she would hit an innocent? She claims to be a Hunter! She should go after someone whose death would help the village. And if she misses, well, then it's simply as if she would have similarly likely missed had she been killed otherwise too.

++Sally

DON'T HUNT ME. I am not a wolf. :mad: :rolleyes:

I'm fallible like the rest of you. I'm hunting someone I find suspicious, but I could be wrong. :eek:

Seriously I think hunter Sally would play smarter than this.

Speaking of Lhuna et al, I "like" how half people haven't appeared at all.

Yeah, she's a wolf.

Geeeez stop trolling!

I'd love to, but I'm sick and busy. :(


I still have time to change my pick, so we'll see what happens.

We're still relatively early in the game, so the chances of a hunter picking an innocent is relatively high and worth the risk for the wolves. It's in the end game that a hunter is very powerful.

Exactly my point!

Ok fine. Good luck if you're the Hunter Sally. So long if you're not. I'll miss your insouciance either way.
++ Sally

ok no. this nails it. A NAME? NO? THEN DIE AND CURSE IN VAIN

:rolleyes:

5 minutes guys

Do something!

++sally

Her blood be on us and on our children.

++Sally

-shrug emoji-

I'm on the fence, but anybody who actually wants to save Sally goofed it up by not coming up with an alternative in time... :rolleyes:

Topic for the next Day: "Who among those who abstained from voting (or voted when it matters no more) are Wolves, et cetera."

Let's just kill Lottie and be safe. ;)




I'm beyond giving a crap. Rude. :p

Well, since I only remember you mentioning that you suspect me and Pitch, I would like to remind you that we both voted for Huinwolf at a time when those votes meant he shot up in likelihood of being quarantined. Don't hunt either of us. There are WAY more suspicious people. The fact that you only mentioned us makes me like 90% sure you are a wolf, but if you're really the Hunter and you kill me, I swear, you will be so embarrassed.

++Sally

If she's the hunter, I don't understand why she would not say her pick.

X-ed with a bunch of posts