The first two people on the list to receive THREE votes advances, so no, Thingol and Finduilas have not been officially elected.

In addition, the rule is we can only vote for one of these people at a time. To cast another vote we must wait until two other Downers cast a vote. Thus, either Thingol or Finduilas does not currently have a vote (for the sake of the tally I subtracted Thingol's vote).

I will cast my vote for Elrond.

Elrond-1
Finduilas-1
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-0
Fingolfin-0

Sorry for any confusion. Just vote for one
at a time in this prelim. Thanks.
Think I'll go with Cirdan, since he was active
in Middle-earth since before the Noldor returned
to Beleriand through into the Fourth Age.

Elrond-1
Finduilas-1
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-0

First to get to three votes gets in. (I just thought it would
be a way to give everyone's favorite not yet in na chance).

Oh, duh. Sorry about that; I thought you meant the next two to get thirded (since all had two) not the first in this list to receive three votes. My mistake. *blushes*

I'll go for Finduilas and Fingolfin. But where did Thingol's first vote disappear?

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0 (1?)
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1

The idea was to have one vote at a time as a sort of playoff to get
the last candidate, for a total of 20. So how about counting your first cited vote
(for Finduilas)? If so, and therefore not counting Thingol's vote, the
total so far would be

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-0

Again, sorry for the confusion.

I'll vote for Voronwë, making the total:

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-1
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-0

And now a vote for Fingolfin-

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-1
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1

Ok,let's finish this. I'll vote for Finduilas again.

Elrond-1
Finduilas-3
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-1
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1

Thanks to all for voting and putting up with errors.

And now for something completely different. Twenty elves enter.
One elf leaves.
Let the kinslaying begin.

RULES

From 20 to 7 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts are allowed.

From 6 to 4 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts ar not allowed: a player has to hurt 2 different characters and heal one, or he may use only 1 hurt and 1 heal.

When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.

Wait for at least three posters to vote prior to you voting again.

This Hurt and heal is dedicated to elves.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

Hurt Amarie and Idril, Heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

Double hurt Maedhros(for me namesake),heal Aredhel
Aredhel ar-feiniel (12)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (8)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

Hurt Aredhel and Finduilas; heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

Hurt Aredhel and Amarië, heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

EDIT:crossed with Mnemo and didn't notice until now.

Hurt Amarie and Idril, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

Heal Idril, Double hurt Luthien (for Finrod).

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

Double hurt Maedhros,heal Idril:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (12)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

not a vote....
 

Merely a voting update, as it's easy to get off count with X-posting...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

Hurt Nerdanel Hurt Maglor Heal Amarie

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

Double Hurt Amarie, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

Double Hurt Finduilas; heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

Hurt Luthien; Hurt Maeglin; Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

Help Idril Celebrindal Double Hurt Caranthir

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

Double Hurt Amarie, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (13)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

Double hurt Maedhros,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

Heal Maedhros, double hurt Finduilas.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (5)

Heal Fea, double hurt Finduilas.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)

Double-hurt Aredhel, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)

Now what is this crusade against Finduilas? C'mon!

Heal Finduilas, double hurt Amarië (who knows about her and her character anyway?), stayed in Valinor... *phewwt*

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (2)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

One double hurt to Amarië and you get yourself to the killer list! :rolleyes:

Kill Amarië. :Merisu:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (deaded)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Beleg

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (deaded)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

Kill Amarië.

Double hurt Idril, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

***************

Amarië killed by Sally

In the rush for the kill, I forgot to add that I was heaingl Maedhros as well. Thus, an updated tally as such.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Hurt Eol and Aredhel, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Heal Finduilas, double-hurt Beleg (what a fine elf, but how bad in choosing his alignments!)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (5)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Double hurt Finduilasl, heal Fea

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Hurt Feanor Hurt Maedhros Heal Galadriel
(cross posted, corrected)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Double hurt Idril, heal Maedhros.


Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Double-hurt Luthien; heal Maedhros:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (13)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Hurt Finduilas (preparing her for the kill) and Legolas (somebody has to do it), heal Maglor.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (13)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (2)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

Kill Finduilas; heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (14)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)