Well now I feel really stoopid ... :rolleyes: :D

I had a similar concern, arising from the fact that the Vampire Seer will be able (at Night) to discuss their dreams with their comrades. But my response was slightly different. I would suggest that there be no Vampire Seer. The Vampires have the most knowledge anyway, so giving them the potential to gain more might tip the balance in their favour. It should be up to the Vampires (as with regular Werewolves) to try to spot the Gifteds from what is said during the day. And removing the Vampire Seer will probably removed any need to enable the Villager Gifteds to communicate during the Day.

I'm fine with the other Vampire Gifteds, however, and with the other rules. It is all rather tempting, I must admit, so I shall confirm my availability for selection, albeit with the usual caveat that I may not have time to be as involved as normal (this, of course, being a caveat that I inevitably find myself unable to stick to ...).

Hmm... True, though I wouldn't want to abandon the VSeer...

Would it be enough if the good Gifteds knew each other?

Wouldn't this game work better if we had about 30 players? Much like the Duelling Wizards game.

when was the last time we got a werewolf game up to 30 players? easier said then done my dear Eomer...

Well, I would still want at least four players. I wonät start the game for maybe a week so there is enough time to gather people.

16 already looks pretty good. Four more I agree would be excellent.

With twenty players I'm no more worried about the number of kills.

I think the solution that we have the whole range of gifteds on both sides is okay as long as those both sides have the same possibilities of using their shared information to the common good. So if we have all vampire-gifteds who can plot during the Night together and share their views & knowledge, we should also allow the innocent-gifteds to do the same - either by Night or by Day - via PM.

That might even the things out a bit.

This looks like a lot of fun, I must say.

Another week, you say? Well, if 50 people simultaneously sign up tomorrow, I'll be gone on Friday. No computer access, bah!

Volo, yes, I meant via PM. One big advantage that the Vampires have over the villagers is their ability to communicate. With the advantages they already have, we could at least have them share that with the good gifted.


And remember, no kill list for the vampires means no lists for the gifted. It's true that a kill could be avoided, but so could a hunt or a dream.

I remain uncomfortable about the Vampire Seer, which seems to me to be an incredibly powerful role, and that power transfers to the Vampire team as a whole by virtue of the ability to transmit the dream information gained to them.

While allowing Gifted villagers to communicate would redress the balance to a degree, I have never been much of a fan of Gifted villagers being able to communicate (with limited exceptions, such as Shirrifs) as I think it detracts from two of the aspects of the game that I enjoy - the isolation of being a villager (whether Gifted or ordo) and the challenge of trying to work out who's who by oneself (or rather, when one can only trust one's own thoughts). Similarly, if the Vampires have a Seer, part of the challenge for them disappears.

Incidentally, if the village Seer dreams of a Vampire, will they discover that Vampire's specific role or simply that he/she is a Vampire?

Couldn't the kill list issue be avoided if you require the subject of the riddle, if posted, to post a "victim" within 12 hours of the end of the Day? There may be time issues, I suppose. Is everyone able to check in every twelve hours? It shouldn't affect the Vampire discussions too much anyway, as they could still discuss potential kills in the meantime and decide on a "back-up" kill if their first choice is taken down by the lynch seer.

Also, am I right in understanding that we wil all know our own riddle? It seems to me that it might be more fun if we did not, and so the lych seer has to solve the riddle before being able to post a "victim". Only problem with that, I suppose, is that people might post a victim on the off-chance that they are the lynch seer.

Finally, while games with much in excess of 20 players can be fun, they can also be very difficult to get to grips with as a player and so extremely time-consuming. As someone whose time constraints often conflicts with my desire to participate fully, that does slightly concern me.

I really don't think I'm going to be available from May 6th until possibly even August 15th or later due to some major plans for the summer, so I'd prefer a shorter game myself. Not that I expect the game to last until May 6th, but...

Oh, and I also think the good Gifteds should be able to PM each other.

what is the planned first day?

because i am away on may 3rd to may 7th, and again on may 18th to may 20th, so thats 7 days of me possibly being out of it... if its after that or before (like within next week) then i should be good

*was directed here by a friend* If y'all don't mind me jumping in, I'd like to sign up. :)

I see that there are problems with the time... Well, I have problems with that too. Hmm... Ok, I'll start the game when we get 20 players. I'll spam about this game via PM.

I don't know about this... After all, the Villagers will outnumber the Vampires, and giving the Good Gifteds the ability to PM will make them nearly as strong as the Vampires. Remember that through the lynch seer system we'll get many nearly known Good people!

The Vampire Seer won't replace the Vampires' need for logical thinking. The VSeer can go wrong and dream about an Ordo. Also I'll post the role to the VSeer in the end of the Night, so that it won't be able to tell it before the next Night starts.

Haven't thought about this. Both are fine with me, though I prefer that the specific role won't be told. I don't think this will matter too much.

The Night is full of chaos... I don't think I'll make any rules about when what should happen, as long as it happens during the night. This game is sadly very effected by when people can be online. The Lynch Seer process can filled with strategy: If the Lynch Seer posts the riddle early, the Vampires will get hints whom not to kill, if the Lynch Seer posts the riddle late, the To-be-lynched person might not get a chance to post his/her victims name. The later the To-be-lynched person posts the name of his/her victim, the bigger the probability that the Vampires will try killing an already dead person. But the same goes for the Gifteds, the less time they have to chose a person who's not dead already.

You'll know the riddle about yourself (Kath, we should better start thinking about these.).

I don't fully understand what you're saying there.
The Lynch Seer won't know whose riddle it is for sure when he/she posts it.
The Lynch Seer doesn't chose the victim, he/she choses only if the To-be-lynched person may chose a victim.

I agree that the first day will be hard for everybody, but after it the number of players will drop quickly.

Welcome! Here's the thread where you can introduce yourself. Be aware that this game might be hard for beginners. Wish fun to you and everybody else!

It's great to see so much interest so fast. And for all these new player to the Downs...welcome. :)

Well, the game certainly does look complicated. I'm still slightly confused, but that is probably due to the fact I haven't had much time to think it over (all these papers I have to write for school is making me brain-dead)....I'll take a better look later in the evening when I actually have some time. But I think everything should become quite clear once the game begins.

Volo - Do you think you could place all the rules that have been discussed into one post? That may help some...

Also, is there a deadline for when you want our bios sent to you? I haven't worked on it yet, but I promise I'll get it to you ASAP. Once I get this paper I'm currently writing out of the way, I'll have much more time on my hands.

Well, I for one most say that I'll definitely not be able to check in every 12 hours... or I guess so...

Wait... do you mean a wolf/vampire/whatever-evil-being can't be the lynch seer? :confused:

Oh, there is time. A day before the first Day begins. Oh, indeed: The game starts with a Day!

Help some? :D Me most of all!
Yes, sure I'll try getting it all together.

Sure it can! But it will need some nerve to give an Innocent a free kill. ;) It's all very complicated. I'm sure you'll have long discussions about it during the game. "Why would X do that if Y is Z and A might be C." :D

Haha, this'll be really fun! :D :D

Voting and gifts!
 

This isn't decided yet, but probably the voting and using your special gifts will happen through E-mail! I hope this ok?

Votes and dreams/kills/protection/everything will happen by sending an E-mail to wwthelostage@gmail.com

The format should be:

Topic: The number of the Night/Day and "Day"/"Night". F.ex. for the first Day's votes: "1 Day"

In the textbox: Clearly put the name of the player and what you want to do with him. F.ex. "Vote: Macalaure" or "Dream: Meneltarmacil". And don't forget to put your own BD name!

A full example:

Topic:
2 Night

Textbox:
Protect: Aganzir

-Volo


I hope this is fine. :)

I decided to make the Lynch Seer more powerful. Not he/she will not only get the riddle but also the number of votes for that person. It will help seeing who lie during the next day.

Ok?


I also changed the rule about the To-be-lynched person having to kill if the Lynch Seer writes his riddle in the thread. The T-b-l doesn't have to kill, but it's advisable. :Merisu:

Gah, we should get an "evil" smile here... Something like http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b2...alds/bite2.gif

By my reckoning, we have 17 already, so only 3 more required. 20 players seems a good number for this kind of game.

Makes sense to me. I am not in favour of villager Gifteds being able communicate.

Fair enough. I still think it's a very powerful role but if you want VSeer, I'm fine with that.

It could make a difference, particularly given the powerful nature of the VSeer. With Vampire Gifteds in the game, my vote would be to allow the villager Seer to spot Vampire roles.

Good points. Forget the timing thing and let's go with no Vampire/Gifted kill lists.

Sorry, my mistake. I got mixed up. I was wondering whether it might be more fun if the lynchee would have to solve their own riddle before being able to post a victim, rather than knowing it beforehand.

I think that we could all do with a statement of the rules once they have been finalised, preferably at the beginning of the game thread.

can we have at least a day's notice of the start please?

Presumably, though, it is possible for both the lynchee and the lynch seer to be a Vampire.

Fine by me. I'm on gmail too.

This is shaping up to be a great game ... :smokin: :D

It's all already there. I think all is pretty well cleared in the first rules post (and its links).

Sure. I think nobody will be left out of info with this discussion rate, I'll start posting the story parts as soon as we have at least 20 players.

Yes, but that will put the Vampi... aargh. Discuss this when the game starts! ;) :D

I know - I'm already plotting though I even don't know what my role or side will be! :D
Fair enough... *remembers own newbie times* ;)

Regrettably, I need to withdraw my name from the signups. Sorry!! This sounded like a lot of fun!

I know it would be a lot of fun to have fex. exactly 20 players, but waiting for too long is not wise either. Lately we've had one more player in but one has already left (so we're still in 17?). So I think Volo might just throw us a beginning date like Monday or Tuesday and then we would play with all those people who we have then. Waiting for an indefinitive time to fill up a fixed number of players may turn against itself and the numbers start falling down with all the RL issues (so far we know that Gil can't be in the game after May 3rd, Menel after May 6th).

Welcome Shastanis Althreduin! Have fun!

Have you Volo any basic guidelines concerning the characters? You said they should be human, but then...

From the first post I can gather that we're going to be at least a bit on the lighter side with them. But should they be relating to some actual cultural habitats in the ME? Should they be modern ones or could they be anything (resulting is post-modern mix of very differnet kinds of characters)?

That reminds me... I need to send that. :)

And ha ha, Miyu, I know who you are now. :P

Huh... I'm sorry, the information I gave there is indeed misguiding.

First of all I want to say that I'll take freedom, probably very little, in changing the characters to fit the story. I might also take some freedom in other matters of the game, but you'll just have to trust me with that, in no means will I try to spoil anybody's game.

The characters. Human (not of Numenor). Middle of second age. Funny but not over the top. Think of making a "basic normal human". You may well give your character skills with wielding weapons or any other possible (or not possible, but then it will remain only in your character's head. F.ex. if your character has the skill that he/she can cast fireballs, he/she will try and believe doing that in need, but it won't help him/her too much...) skills, but you won't be able to carry anything but your clothes to the game.

I must appologise to those who have already sent their characters with ideas better than what I allow. All of the characters are good otherwise, but little changes (either by me or you) will be made.


About starting the game. I'll (just now, sorry, forgot...) spam via PM to get more players. We'll also have to make up all the riddles with Kath and some preparations before the game can begin.

About riddles. If you have any great ideas about the riddle about yourself, you can share them. You'll know the riddle about yourself anyway, so the only thing you'll miss this way is what me and Kath might invent...

Resistance is futile
 

I think I may have to play this game... :D

I may just have to jump back into a werewolf game. Sign me up if there's still room.

Since saying no to Volo just isn't right, I'll drop in for the game.

PS: ME Idol results are finally in. :)

Thank you very much for joining! It's great to see all of you long gone people!

Wow that was quick, nice job Volo :)

Welcome Celuien, Sleepy, and Kitanna, good to see all of you back in. :D

That takes us up to 20 doesn't it Volo? Want to call that enough? That way the game can start pretty soon.

19 if can still count right in this state.

I think we could start starting (I know, sounds very very evasive...). Everybody or as many as possible, whom I PMd should get the chance to join. (I might have gone a bit too excited with those PMs :o )

Ah, what the gah, I'll open the game thread now. You can still join if you want.


And to be on the safe side: Everybody understands the rules and agrees to obey them?

And #2: Post your character stuff if you want to!

Sleepy! Kitanna! Celuien! YAY! Some more old faces return! This will be fun. :D

Oh, bother. I'll play.

Well, that is, I'll play unless Nogrod will slander, maim, or kill me for not being very...erm...'loud.' The school year may be almost over, but...we're all procrastinators at heart.

*applause* Yeehaw! Durelin! That's great you decided to play! Welcome on board! :cool:

That means we are 20, right? The right number to start :)

Awesome! With Durelin we have 20 lucky ones! Now for the hard part... riddles... :rolleyes:

I'll still let people to sign in for a while. And start the game thread with the completely irrelevent story.

Well, now all we need is Kuru, Fea, Phantom, Valier, and LMP.....