Lothlorien is the only place Gandalf is not mention to have been in the LotR trilogy?

Reason is completely wronf there. Gandalf did go to Lothlorien after he came back from the dead. He was flown to Lothlorien on Galadriel's orders and was given clothes and he stayed there for a week or so (I think I'm wrong about that) and then headed to Edoras. Guess again!! :p :D

Ah yes, so he did. Well, it's been a while since I read the books ^_^;

The reason is more important than the place ;) ... im not going to continue this thread...

Oh come Telchar, I'm pretty sure you'd be able to get it. Remember, it still has something to do with Hobbit, but more importantly, a Baggins.

There's your hint.

Seriously, Im lost! Bilbo never went to neither Lothlorien or Fangorn. Frodo never went to Mirkwood or Fangorn... :(

Ok, you got it. I know that was difficult, and there are numerouse possibilites for that, but that's what I wanted, Bilbo never went to Lothroien. I hate it when there's numerous answers because then you just want to give it to that person!!! :mad: GRRR!!!! Sorry that I had to put you all through that. :( I truly am!!! :(

ok - here goes

Hobbiton
Long Cleeve
Nobottle
Needlehole

:rolleyes:

Long Cleeve is the only one in North-farthing/not in West-farthing.

The only thing I could think of, just now.

Its a nice guess Rune, but sorry, no. It thas nothing to go with the four farthings...

Is the odd out Long Cleeve. Its the only Took village.

no - as always when I post odd outs - one stands out because the others have something in common. Being "not-a-took-village" isn't much to have in common :p

HINT: Its geographical!

:o :o :D

Is it Long Cleeve, doesnt lay near a river and the others do.

Thats good enough for me :) Long Cleeve is odd out for not being situated on The Water

Thanks Telchar,

• Carchost

• Minas Ithil

• Thousand Caves

• Barad dur

ill go with the thousand caves, as it has no tower.

No sorry,

Hint *The Thousand Caves is not the odd out.*

Barad Dur, only place not to be held by different races

(Carchost - Orcs and men)
(Minas Ithil - orcs and men and nazgul)
(Thousand Caves - men and dwarves)

No but good guess.

Carchost...nothing lived in it

No thats not it

I'm going to guess at Minas Ithil. It was the only building constructed by Numenoreans.

Warm but no

OOOOO!!! So it is Minas Ithil. Or, I'm pretty sure it is. Now to think of a reason.....It was the only one that got taken over by orcs? That's probably wrong.....

Carchost was taken over by orcs...


Minas Ithil...only place to be taken and left standing during the Last Alliance?
(Barad Dur was destoryed but foundations left, Carchost was built after the Last Alliance)

No no its not Minas Itil :D but your reason was not so far off from the reason I'm looking for.

Barad Dur then? with the reasons stated above

Its not the reason I'm looking for, but you are looking in the right direction.

so its Barad Dur...any hints?

*HINT* Thousand Caves is the odd out

But you said earlier that it's not the odd out. I'm so confused!! :confused: :(

care to explain Esta?

:eek: :o :o

Can I explain that, sorry for that. But anyway it is the odd out.

Ok, if it is the odd out, is it because no no Hobbit explored in it or because it's not man made? I think both of those are wrong but hey, it's worth a shot, right?

it was the only one that was a cave?
or possibly it was the only one named in Common. Minas Ithil, no, Carochost, no, Barad-dur, no....well its right but might not be correct ;)

only one inhabited by dwarves?

All good guesses, but No, no and nope.

Thousand Caves because it's the only First Ager? (Destroyed in the First Age, that is)

Yes thats it.
Floor is yours

:)

Amon Hen
Emyn Beraid
Hill of Erech
Ravenhill
Weathertop