Ah, Ok, so the ONE FREAKING 100% KNOWN INNOCENT IN THIS GAME has evil intent.

Hm, like I said, wolf playing a cobbler - or else a cobbler who thinks a wolf is up for the lynch and is desperately trying to draw votes away.

Boro, I have a sneaking suspicion that, though Mac and Kath may well both be evil, by not voting alongside Lommy you've doomed us all (well, you living ones). :(

Or perhaps Lommy will switch to Kath? I suppose it's still hopeless.

Just because someone is innocent, doesn't mean they don't have schemes of their own. xD


X'd with Rikae.

I don't understand Izzy's vote. True, there is no hard evidence to believe Greenie's Seer claim, but then again there is no hard evidence to disbelieve it.

In fact, all evidence in this game is circumstantial. And I hazard the opinion that there is more circumstantial evidence in favor of Greenie's claim than against it.

She did vote for him, though.
RL situation has come up, meaning I can't put near the time into this it deserves.
I was leaning toward Mac, who I already suspected, or Kath, because of the Gwath vote. I still think he's more likely to be a conspirator than mutineer, and modfire looks definately to be likely for him.
Izzy's vote is bizarre enough, but does it scream 'mutineer' or just 'conspirator? No time to consider it further right now.
Again, my apologies. I'll try to do better next Day, even if I'm a ghost.

Yes, agreeing with Boro. He's wrong about the ghost lynches, but I think he has the right of this.

++ Kath

x'd with Shasta

Hum. I find Gwath-voters strange at this juncture, same with Mira before. I'm not sure that in itself is enough to declare Kath guilty, though.

Shasta, she claimed earlier today that "almost every person" who called her lists "fabricated" (which I did yesterday) had evil intent, even though I had already been proven to be the hunter. Sure, she said almost - but still, the only point in saying it was to imply a known innocent was evil. She's obviously evil - don't waste your time.

I don't want to sound as repeating myself but just take a look at yesterDay. Rikae went pretty strongly against Gwath (as much as I have read yesterDay). So if the mutineers believed Rikae was the hunter (why wouldn't they as she was the hunter) they would not have attacked her if Gwath was one of them. Or then they are very confident indeed and could sacrifice Gwath - who hasn't posted a lot lately anyway.

EDIT: Bah... I posted for the previous page only... needs to see more...

Given that Gwath seems to be heading for modfire anyway, I move that we move the discussion onward. :p

I'm always afraid of Kath when innocent - and this time is no exception...

But my God if this is one more mutineer bandwaggon!

The problem is whether they (the mutineers) feel really confident or not... The missed kill would talk for them having problems - and it would fit Kath being one as she wouldn't be there on the deadline to make sure the kill gets through...

Who would be the clumsy American(s) then missing a shot during the Night? That would be something to think for toMorrow...

A quick list:

Lommy - still leaning innocent with her, though I could see her as a very skilled cobbler, too.
Inzy - hasn't done anything to make suspect him of cobblery less than yesterday.
Boro - leaning more innocent with him today than yesterday.
Shasta - has slipped a bit from my attention lately.
Kath - Her Gwath-vote is a bad one, but I have the feeling that she hasn't entirely caught up yet. She also forgot that Eomer was killed. I'd like to give her a pass for today.
Izzy - probably not a mutineer, but could be a cobbler.
Mith - another one I paid too little attention to. Doesn't seem evil, though.
Eonwe - needs a closer look, too.

If I only knew how many mutineers are actually hiding within those 8. It has to be at least 2. Would Lommy really launch an attack like that if she was a mutineer? Is Inzy more evil than I thought? Am I wrong about Boro? Or Izzy? Or is lynching Kath the best option after all? I need a better picture of Shasta, Mith, and Eonwe...

Heh, not only Kath, but Mith and Lommy could also be ones to leave the duty of reporting the kill to someone in the US. because of the terrible DL and then be implied as well if there are more mutineers left...

That's a thought that makes Mac look more innocent after all - he's here in the US and would have been unlikely to miss the kill.

Only got the mental energy to look at the three today.

Shasta is quite keeping his head out of things. Not one actual accusation the entire day. He is helpful, though, and I agree with most of his stated opinions.

I like it how Mith cautioned people against the early Kath suspicions. Her vote is puzzling. Didn't do much else.

Eonwe suddenly started this whole idea that the mutineers might kill each other at night. Then he votes out of gut feeling. Definitely worthy of a raised eyebrow, but wouldn't a mutineer give more effort to look reasonable?

That didn't really help...

...which would be just what Mac would want to do, and maybe Nog too. (Could I have actually killed an aggressor after all?)

Oh, and Izzy, you do have to eat your words, then, since my only "scheme" was to point out a possible bit of wolvishness from your potentially wolfish self. :p

*sprinkles some pepper on Rikae's words for her*

xD

You guys are taking Short Ruth Mith's job. :(

I still think Lommy - Mac was staged.

It might have been a ploy on Lommy's side (which would make her a very likely cobbler), but not from mine.

Nerwen -> Gwath
Mith -> Izzy
Lommy -> Mac
Kath -> Gwath
Eonwe -> Inzy - not bolded, does not count
Izzy -> Nerwen
Boro -> Kath

Gwath 2. Izzy, Mac, Nerwen, Kath 1. Inziladun, Shasta, Mac, and Gwath left to vote.

I don't like that Gwath is in the lead, at all. It's going to take two votes to not let that happen, which means... Mac and I have to vote the same, on someone who's already got one vote. Unless Zil shows up (which I doubt).

Sadly you didn't... I'd give you all the credit if you'd done that, but sorry. You chose soo wrong... :(

Let's see if we can work anything out toMorrow. Now I'm just too tired and enough disinterested to try to figure the situation...

Shasta, Inzy voted Kath. Who are you considering voting?

I missed Zil's vote for Kath. So, Gwath is still in line to be executed, but one vote for Kath will tip the scales. Mac and I to vote, and to be honest, I would rather control the vote than someone I consider to be evil.

++Kath

What is your tally about Shasta? At least Inziladun voted for Kath so she has at least two votes...

And really, Gwath is a bad idea I say. Just looking at yesterDay and the kill of the Night - and if he's facing a modfire anyway.

I see you're still around, Mac. As of right now, I still have my retraction, but the only other candidates for lynching are Izzy, yourself, and Nerwen. I think Nerwen innocent based on Greenie's claim, you're obviously not going to vote yourself, and I think Izzy is a cobbler, so.... Kath really is the only option.

Oh, yes. When the game ends and I am revealed to be the secret evil hunter, unknown even to myself, who lies about Izzy's fabricated list without even knowing it, boy will I be embarrassed! :rolleyes:

Guess what Izzy? Your list was fabricated. Fabricated, fabricated, fabricated. Polyester, rayon, satin, wool crepe fabricated! PREfabricated, even! Your list was fabricated, and I saw that it was fabricated, and I said "lo and behold! This post, it is FABRICATED, as it has been ordained by Izzy, and all shall see it and shall say "yea, verily, it is fabricated!" and there shall be great rejoicing, and we shall slaughter the aggressors and have a feast, for so sayeth RIKAE." And all who were gathered there looked upon the post, and said "forsooth, it is fabricated, and Izzy has made it so, and in doing so she sinneth against the almighty crew, and she shall be cut into four pieces (not three, five is right out) and thrown into the sea, where the fishes and the sharks and the birds of the air and all the lifeguards and surfers shall feast upon her and shall not die, for she has made a fabricated post, and the one who pointed it out had not evil intent nor ulterior motive"! And it was so.

I have a feeling we're choosing wrongly here, but alright:

++Kath

Who would you rather have lynched, then, Mac? Not yourself, I'm guessing.

So you din't go for Izzy, Mac? Why is that?

And still you regret voting Kath?

Interesting...

Izzy seems wasted, Nerwen and Gwath are out of the question, and young Master Eonwe forgot to bold his vote for the formidable choice Inziladun. :rolleyes:

Kath is indeed the best choice right now, and that's sad.

Give me a reason to believe she's a mutineer.

Truer words you have never spoken! Bwahaha! :D

Erm, I just meant to say that lynching her would be a waste of a lynch. *curses language* :o

--Gwath

++Izzy

Most obviously evil person, and though she looks more cobbler-ish, that might be deliberate.

Mac: A known innocent seems to have a strong case on her. I have not read most of the discussions on the last two Days and can't give you one myself. Maybe later if I have an interest and time to actually read things through.

Just asking... it's interesting to know why you make your decisions and how you do it. And requiring that from you alive-voters helps the general cause as you need to react to these beggings in one way or another.

Snapping back to a ghost isn't the best one I'd say... :smokin:

Heck.

--Kath

++Izzy

...What the heck? Fools!

Oh boy - I bet that is what she wants...

EDIT: I wasn't so much making a case against her (there's no need to) as bantering... I bet she's a cobbler...

EDIT 2: and the other is Greenie... Nerwen a wolf... with Mac and Kath...

Quite possibly... but I wasn't so sure about Gwath anymore. I didn't know who else to pick.

Don't be silly.

Yeesh, all the last minute voting...makes it hard to count when I'm tired. I believe the lynch is Kath, but maybe someone should double check me on that. :rolleyes: