That's right. Your turn. :cool:

They all wrestled with the mind of the dark lord?

Close, but not it.

They've all seen the Eye of Sauron?

Got it! Your turn, Elf-Warrior.

Grimbold
Halbarad
Théoden

They were all killed in the Battle of the Pelennor?

Correct. It's your turn paavo.

Thanks!
 

New one:

Bilbo
Gandalf
Glóin

They all visited Elrond?

Nope.

They all spoke at the council of Elrond?

Not that either.

They normally all wear hats when they go for a walk :D

Good try, but no. :) Actually it was such a good answer that if nobody will answer, say in two days, you can have the thread.

Maybe a hint will help ;)

Think about other books as well, not just the lord of the rings...

They all survived the Battle of Five Armies?

argh, I really hate this game because everyone thinks up much better answers than me, but still not the correct one. :( :) So just keep on guessing.

They all went on the journey to kill Smaug and get the gold!

All there names start with a curved letter? :p

no and no. :)

they all smoked pipes

Their names all have an L in them?

If you combine the elf-warriors and Evisses answer and think where these happened you might find the correct answer.

They were all in Rivendell?

I've had enough of my stupid question! :mad: The correct answer was that they all appeared in both The Hobbit and the Lord of the rings. Anyone can get the next question. :)

*CPRs thread*

Beorn
Aragorn
Gandalf

THey all came at unexpected times turning the tide of a major battle
Beorn: battle of five armies
Gandalf: Helm's Deep
Aragorn: Pellenor

I would say thaat's right

'but I'll wager a guess

They all formed great bonds with horses

Beorn had his watch-horse if you will
Aragorn had brego
and Gandalf had shadowfax

arcticstorm has it.

Bilbo
Eomer
Beregond

All of them wronged their lord...

This thread is loong over due....

Theoden
Beren
Aragorn
Tuor

They all had a son as the oldest child?

nope

They were all kings?

They all were kings of peoples they hadn't grown up among? (Sorry for the word order, my English not at sharpest today; I hope you understood.)

And if I get this correct, I will hand the thread over to JennyHallu, since it was because of her that I got this.

They all married people of another race/people? I know it fits badly with Theoden, but his wife was Gondorian, IIRC.