Is it a mortal?

Edit: post # 2000!!! :D :eek: Wow!

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No

Congrats on reaching 2000 :D

....I'll be super excited in a few when I reach 250, but suddenly that seems to be so few....

Is it an ainu?

Thanks! :)

I was super-excited on every milestone, but when it got to over 500 I stopped paying attention to it, and I missed my 1000th post. :o

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No

An Elf?

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes

Born in the First Age?

A noldo?

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes
Born in the First Age? - Yes
A noldo? - No

Does he/she die?

Bath water is good - Rupert Brooke wrote of "the benison of hot water" but the best is a sig Rune had for a while which said that the cure for anything was salt water - sweat, tears, the sea.... okies hijack over. Though Gally dear you will soon overtake the Saucepan Man!

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes
Born in the First Age? - Yes
A noldo? - No
Does he/she die? - Yes

Lived in Doriath?

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes
Born in the First Age? - Yes
A noldo? - No
Does he/she die? - Yes
Lived in Doriath? - Yes

Died in Doriath?

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes
Born in the First Age? - Yes
A noldo? - No
Does he/she die? - Yes
Lived in Doriath? - Yes
Died in Doriath? - Yes

O, so many choices!

Saeros?

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes
Born in the First Age? - Yes
A noldo? - No
Does he/she die? - Yes
Lived in Doriath? - Yes
Died in Doriath? - Yes

Saeros? - No

You could still try and narrow it down a bit, but yes there are so many choices...

Related to Luthien?

Is it a person - Yes
Is it a mortal? - No
Is it an ainu? - No
An Elf? - Yes
Born in the First Age? - Yes
A noldo? - No
Does he/she die? - Yes
Lived in Doriath? - Yes
Died in Doriath? - Yes
Saeros? - No
Related to Luthien? - By Blood? Yes, distantly

Distantly.... hmmmmm.....

Nimloth? Since she's Celeborn's niece, and Celeborn is Elmo's great-grandson or something... that would be quite distant.

Exactly. :D Congrats!

She and Celeborn happen to be favorite characters of mine. ;)

Thanks!

OK, well, I thought of making the "imperishable crystal" that Gimli wanted to set Galadriel's hair in the answer, but I promised something easy. Or, at least, easier.

Well, this one will be easy for sure! :)

Person?

Person - no

Object?

Place?

Person - no

Object - no
Place - yes... but an easy one, promise (not anything like ME) :)

Did Elves live there?

a place that still exists in the Third Age ?

West of the Misty Mts?

North of Orthanc?

Person - no
Object - no
Place - yes

Did Elves ive there - yes
Existed in the 3rd Age - yes
West of Msty Mtns - yes
North of Orthanc - yes

Rivendell?

I hate geography...left is west on a map, right?

Yay! :D It is Rivendell

If the top of the map is north. ;) On a ME map, left is West.

Cool, I'm ready. :D

....I can find countries and fill them in on a blank map, but I couldn't tell you what direction they're in...if that makes sense. ;) Thanks for confirming that left is west on M-E maps. :D

Is it a person?

Is it a person? - No

Another place, maybe?

Is it a person? - No
Another place, maybe? - No