Okay, it has been a few weeks, so I guess I´ll continue with a new quote (maybe it has been posted before, and maybe it is an easy one, but what the heck...) :

Mandos to Ulmo, considering the fate of Earendil, who went to search for his wife.

Of course it is... *smiles* Very good.
Please proceed.

The Númenóreans said this to the messengers of Manwë (in the Akallabêth)

Sorry for the delay, but you were right of course, Guinevere! :)

:) Thank you Mariska!

Jease, i'd say grima if this wasnt the silmarillion.

The guys name who starts with S that Turin killed to Thingolo? :)

Is it Angrod?

@MorgothBauglir: No, it isn't Saeros. But it is said to Thingol!
@Fingolfin II : No, but you're getting very close... ;)

I know it's one of the A's......Aegnor?

No, no one with A... ;)

Finrod

Correct !
 

your turn, Elwe Singollo! :)

"You have my leave but not my love".

I love this quote.

Anyone???

Well I know it's either one of two people, but I don't want to guess them both at once, in fairness to other BD'ers, so........Curufin?

Yep. Curufin said it to Eol when he went looking for Aredhel and Maeglin.

Your turn Fingolfin.

Easy one
 

Ok.....how about-

Well all I can think is Aragorn but he isn't Silmarillion. But I Suppose he maight be in the Of the Rings of Power bit.

I also think that Maedhros said something similar when talking to Fingolfin.

Right you are, Elwe! He said it when he renounced the High Kingship of the Noldor.

Trythis

Huan to Beren.

the phantom has it.

:)

I don't own a copy of The Silmarillion, so all my guesses are mainly educated guesses- I can't check them up. Anyway, I have a feeling that it is Gwindor to Finduilas, talking about Turin.

Your feelings are accurate.

Cool, how about-

tulkas to the rest of the valar

Yep.

.

I think that was Hurin to Mîm.

correct

Oops, I forgot about this thread...

Eonwe to Earendil?

EDIT: I have camp for a week, so if I'm right then anyone can go.

Fingolfin II was right!
But since this thread has been forgotten for some time, I'll post a new one.

Spoken by Galadriel to Melian while living in Doriath.

Absolutely correct!

opps, forgot about this. BUt, here is the next one:

any takers? a clue, perhaps?