Is it an event?

Did it happen or exist in the third age?

First Age?

Is it a place?

Is it alive? Yes
Is it an event? No
Did it happen or exist in the third age? No
First Age? Yes
Is it a place? No

did this person live in the second age?

Is he/she an elf?

Is it an animal?

Male? or Female?

Is it a man?

Did this person live in the second age? No
Is he/she an elf? Yes
Is it an animal? No
Male? or Female? Yes (and no for the second question ;) )
Is it a man? No

Did this Elf ever go to Valinor?

Is it a noldo?

Did said elf have children?

Did this Elf participate in any major battles?

Was this elf a member of a ruling family?

was the elf a ruler of a specific area?

Let's see...
 

So our mystery male Elf died before the Second Age...hmmm...Finrod?

If not, is he of the Sindar?

Was he of the house of Finwe?

Did this Elf ever go to Valinor? No
Is it a noldo? No
Did said elf have children? Not, that I kow.
Did this Elf participate in any major battles? Yes
Was this elf a member of a ruling family? No
was the elf a ruler of a specific area? No
So our mystery male Elf died before the Second Age...hmmm...Finrod? No
If not, is he of the Sindar? Yes, it's a grey one ;)
Was he of the house of Finwe? No

And now it should be easy...

Was it Beleg?

Or maybe Mablung?

How about Annael?

And the winner is...

Thorongil... and so it was Mablung.

Congratultion! http://people.freenet.de/d.bolz-fritzlar/grin.gif
Please go on.

Yay!:D Ask away folks.

First Question!?
 

Oh, first question!

Is it a living thing? :)

Is it of the 3rd age?

Is it an object?

Um...is it male?

Is it an Elf?

is it immortal?

Is it a living thing? -No
Is it of the 3rd age? -No
Is it an object? -Yes
Um...is it male? -No
Is it an Elf? -No
is it immortal? -No

Is it a weapon?

First Age and/or Second Age?

Is it something you can wear?

Is it made of a metal?

did it belong to a member of the fellowship?

Is it an event?


@The Perky Ent: Good question: no 3rd age + fellowship http://people.freenet.de/d.bolz-fritzlar/confused.gif
Sorry couldn't resist ;)

Uh...um...yeah...well...that was a spasm to show how to post on the thread improperly! That was an example! btw, celegorn, where did u get that smilie?

@Celegorm. Good question:

http://people.freenet.de/d.bolz-fritzlar/confused.gif

Sorry couldn't resist. ;)

Ahem ... Is it an item of jewellery?