Is it a weapon? No

Can it be held?

Can it be held? No

Is it man-made?

Is it man-made? Yes

Is it made of Stone?

Is it made of stone? No

Is it made of wood?

Is it made of wood? Yes

Is it a building?

Is it a building? No

Is it used as a mode of transportation?

Is it used as a mode of transportation? Yes

Is it found in the Silm?

Is it found in the Silm? Yes

Does it have a name?

Does it have a name? No

I see . . .
 

Is it the boat used to send Eärendil's crew back to Middle-earth?

Good work, Nilp! You're up.

Yippee!
 

Thanks. :)

Ask away, then.

Is it large?

Is it a person?

Does its name start with a letter between A and L?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.

Is the person male?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.

Is the person male? Yes.

Did he live during the Third Age?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.

Did he live during the Third Age? No.

Is he an Elf?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.

Is he an Elf? No.

Maybe a Dwarf?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.

Maybe a Dwarf? No.

1st Age?

5th straight 'No' wins you a clue.
 

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.

1st Age? No.

Númenorean?

Combo-breaker!
 

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.

Númenorean? Yes

Did he spell his name in Adûnaic?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes

Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.

Was he of the Line of Elros?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes
Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.

Was he of the Line of Elros? Yes.