All but the Silmarils were possesed by Frodo at the time to the War of the Ring?

close, but no

I came up with a stupid answer, and tried to delete this post, but it didn't work. Hold on while I think of something else...

EDIT (to save bandwidth...I know, Saucie would be so proud! ;) ): K, got something: Frodo's mithril vest was the only one that didn't hurt the "bad guy". The Silmaril burnt Morgoth and Ungoliant (Right??? Sorry, it's been so long! *sheepish grin*), Sting, well, obviously, and the Phial burnt Shelob's eyes.

P.S. Sorry to keep you waiting Perky!

Alrighty! I've got all the time in the world :) :\ :| :/ :( Not really, but you get the point!

EDIT - Nope, still off. It's not what it did and think about your previous post.

All but the Silmarils were used to aid the Ringbearer, and without said objects, he wouldn't have succeeded?

The Silmarils were the only ones not given to Frodo as a gift?

All except the Silmarils where owned by Frodo? Nah, too easy... All except the Silmarils were given as gifts?

How about...

All but the silmarils saved frodo from getting killed?

Nope. My thing is kinda corny, so keep that in mind.



EDIT: THIS IS MY 1,001th POST! YAY

Mithril vest - never owned by elves, only dwarves, dragon and hobbits.

right answer, wrong reason

The Silmarils were never owned by hobbits?

In my last post, I said right answer, wrong reason. As in, it's the mithril, but you've got the wrong reason!

Oh, silly me. I'll just blame it on my tiredness. It was 2 am when I posted that. ;)

Mithril Vest because...it wasn't used as a weapon?

snope!

Frodo's mithril vest is the only one of the the four that does not glow or emit light.

nithagope (nope)

The mithril coat is the only garment?

nope, and welcome to the downs!

The mithril vest is the only one not made by Elves?

no sir, and, or, ma'am

I'm a guy :).....how about something obvious- was it the mithril vest because it was the only one made out of mithril?

No. but it's cheezy like that ;)

Mithril Vest - Because we know what material it was made of?

not the vest. And the phial of Galadriel was made out of glass. At least I think so. I'm no expert...

the mithril coat was the only one that was a gift??

as in not the mithril coat!

Im confused earlier u said it was the mithril vest and now its not??

I share wilwarin538's confusion, Perky, as you posted a bit earlier:


I think that some clarification is in order, and perhaps a hint too.

Woah now! i've found the problem. I had one stray post that I must have posted in insanity, but, the answer is, It's not the vest I was refering to the simarils.

Silmarils- only thing made out of unknown material?

Silmarils - made of Silima,,;)
And the Mithril coat was made by the dwarves for an Elven princeling...... hmmm

but I my be being thick but was it the Silmarills or the Mithril mail in the end....

Aaaiiiieeeeeeee *disappears in puff of confusion*

silmarils cause there the only ones who have an intirebook about them? I think this might be a longshot.

I thought they said in the Sil that it was unknown what the silmarils were made of, and the only one who did was Fëanor?

The Silmarils- only ones where a war(s) was waged for?

Bombadil, the Silmarils were made of Silima like Mithalwen said, but you're right in that no-one actually knows what Silima itself is.

So far, no. But I'll give you a hint. Think Geography.

If the Silmarils are the O>O>O ... then because they were the only things made in the undying lands? Seems too simple........

Here's a major hint: It's not where it is, it's where it isn't! That was a big hint. But then, you needed it ;)Mithalwen - No, but keep thinking outside the box ;)

All but the Silmarils passed over to Valinor with members of the War of the Ring? (I'm not sure about this one, it's just a wild shot in the dark.)

Yeah, it is a wild shot. The facts are wrong. So, no.